Synectics
Synectics is a group method that seeks a new solution to a problem through analogy. The group first analyses the problem until it can restate it in its own terms. It then moves away from the problem through fantasy, direct, personal and symbolic analogies. Finally it returns to the problem and compares each analogy with what it has understood. William J. J. Gordon developed the method at Arthur D. Little. George Prince joined him there in 1958. Gordon published it in 1961 in Synectics. The deliverable is a new viewpoint on the problem and a solution principle to test.
Goal
Synectics is a method of group problem solving. It looks for the solution in fields with no apparent connection to the problem. Gordon glosses the Greek word as "the joining together of different and apparently irrelevant elements".
According to Gordon, a group that analyses a problem is quick to find the solutions already known. A new solution needs a new viewpoint: a way of seeing the problem that yields a technical idea for solving it. Synectics produces this viewpoint through mechanisms that the group learns and repeats. It then makes the group hold each analogy up against the problem.
The method supports a decision: which principle to test or which research to launch. It delivers the chosen viewpoint, the principle that follows from it and the trial that will verify it. The session record logs the analogies tried and what each one yielded.
Usage
When to use
- A technical problem with no satisfactory solution: the specialists have tried the known solutions and know their flaws.
- Ideas that all look alike: the group proposes variants of the same solution in the first few minutes.
- A new principle to verify by prototype: find a principle for a product or a system that a model or a trial can test.
- A business rule or process that a pilot can measure: find a new principle, then try it out in one department.
- An innovation programme over several months: train an internal group that works through a series of the organisation's problems.
When not to use
- A principle that no trial can verify: a policy or budget choice remains the group's opinion; compare the options with a multi-criteria decision analysis.
- A culture where a public mistake costs dearly: the personal and fantasy analogies expose the participants; prefer SCAMPER.
- A one-off session without a trained facilitator: use a single analogy within creative thinking.
Description
The two movements
Gordon describes creation as two movements. The first makes the strange familiar: the group analyses the problem until it understands it in its own terms. The second makes the familiar strange: the group distorts, inverts or transposes the problem until it sees it as new. The analogies serve this second movement.
Analysis alone gives superficial solutions. A group that gets stuck in analysis turns it into an end in itself. Analogies alone solve nothing: for Gordon, a string of metaphors that never returns to the problem is unproductive.
The phases
Gordon divides the process into nine phases in Appendix II of his book. He illustrates them with the case of a roof.
- Problem as given. Those who must solve the problem receive a statement. It may hide the real question. It always carries assumptions that may be false. In the roof case, the statement asks the group to invent a new roof.
- Making the strange familiar. The group analyses the problem. It brings to light elements that nobody had seen. It also exposes the elements that contradict each other and does not yet try to reconcile them. The analysis of the roof brings out the functions and the drawbacks of existing roofs. It shows that a white roof in summer would cut air conditioning and that a black roof in winter would cut heating.
- Problem as understood. The group isolates the items of information and restates the problem in its own terms. This phase closes the analysis. The problem as understood becomes a roof that turns from white to black according to heat and sunlight. In summer it is white and reflects the heat. In winter it is black and absorbs it.
- Operational mechanisms. The group forms analogies from the problem as understood. In a session, one analogy calls up another. For the roof, the group asks what changes colour in nature: the weasel, the chameleon, then the flounder.
- The familiar made strange. The problem as understood looks foreign, as if nobody had ever seen it. The group looks at the roof as a flounder's back.
- Psychological states. The mechanisms put the group in the states that Gordon considers favourable to creation: involvement, detachment, deferment of the solution, speculation and the use of the commonplace. Gordon first tried to induce these states directly. He could not do so reliably. The mechanisms are his answer.
- States integrated with problem. The group compares the most relevant analogy with the problem as understood.
- Viewpoint. Each comparison opens a potential viewpoint. It becomes actual when the comparison yields a technical idea. The flounder changes colour when its black pigments rise towards the skin. From this the group derives a black coating studded with white plastic beads. Heat expands the beads and pushes them to the surface: the roof turns white.
- Solution or research target. The group verifies the principle with a trial or hands it over to research. The choice depends on whether the principle recombines known materials or requires new ones to be developed.
During the analysis, the group proposes solutions too soon. When Gordon's group worked on the problem of a constant-speed mechanism, its first ideas were all gears, cones or hydraulic clutches. Competent engineers had already tried them. The group answered with a personal analogy: it made the problem strange instead of resuming the analysis.
For an analyst, phases 1 to 3 cover familiar work: the problem statement, the analysis of the current state and the restatement. Problem shaping often supplies the problem as understood. The part specific to Synectics starts at phase 4.
The mechanisms
Gordon calls the analogies that make the familiar strange operational mechanisms. Each mechanism is a specific mental process.
| Mechanism | What the group does | Gordon's example |
|---|---|---|
| Fantasy analogy | It imagines the ideal solution as if the laws that forbid it did not hold. | A space suit that closes because the wearer wants it closed. Insects join the edges of the opening. |
| Direct analogy | It compares the problem with facts, knowledge or techniques from another field. Gordon draws mostly on biology. | A roof that changes colour like the flounder. |
| Personal analogy | Each participant identifies with an element of the problem and describes what it does and feels. | The participants step mentally into a box and try to keep the speed of a shaft constant. |
| Symbolic analogy | It describes the function with an objective and compressed image, even one that is technically wrong. | The Indian rope trick for a jack that fits into a small box. |
Fantasy analogy comes first when the group makes the familiar strange. The group imagines the ideal solution. Gordon calls this attitude conscious self-deceit: the participant knows the laws that contradict the solution and pretends they do not exist. Gordon puts it first because it restates the problem in imaginary terms. It links the statement of the problem to its solution. It also calls up the other mechanisms. To seal a space suit, the group asks: "How do we in our wildest fantasies desire the closure to operate?" It moves from insects that join the edges to a spider that sews up the opening. It arrives at springs embedded in two rubber lips and pulled together by a wire.
Direct analogy compares the problem with parallel facts, knowledge or techniques. Gordon cites Marc Isambard Brunel, who watched a shipworm. This mollusc bores into wood and lines its tunnel with a tube. Brunel drew from it a method for building under water. After seventeen years of research, Gordon considers biology the richest source. Its vocabulary stays clear to a non-specialist. Living things suggest analogies for problems stated purely in figures.
Gordon ranks direct analogies by the knowledge they demand. At one end of the scale the image is naive: a group designed a one-piece dispenser on the model of an animal sphincter, then built it. At the other end, the flounder gave a viewpoint because one participant knew how the fish's pigment cells change its colour.
Personal analogy asks the participant to identify with an element of the problem. The participant gives up the position of the expert who observes from outside. For the constant-speed mechanism, the input shaft turns at between 400 and 4000 revolutions per minute. The output shaft must hold 400 revolutions per minute. Each member steps mentally into the box that links the two shafts and tries to hold this speed with their own body. One of them imagines an elastic fluid made of rubber bands that wind onto the axis as the speed rises. The model built on this principle transmitted power poorly. A mechanical equivalent then proved the principle.
This mechanism demands a loss of self that some participants experience as a threat. The trainer enters the box first. The novice sees what happens to someone else and stops fearing the loss of control.
Symbolic analogy describes the problem with an objective and impersonal image. Gordon defines it as a compressed description of the function. The image can be technically wrong and still satisfy the mind. It comes all at once like a poet's turn of phrase. Personal analogy takes more time. A group is looking for a jack that fits into a box about 10 cm square, extends by about 90 cm and carries about 3.6 tonnes. One participant mentions the Indian rope trick: the rope goes in soft and comes out rigid. The group arrives at two bicycle chains that each bend in only one direction. The chains run apart inside the casing. As they come out, they lock onto each other and form a rigid column.
A later classroom version reduces symbolic analogy to a compressed conflict: two words that contradict each other ("heavy lightness"). Gordon does not describe this form in 1961.
The group and the roles
Gordon brings together five to seven people from different occupations. He selects them by interview, then trains them.
| Role | What it does | Gordon's rule |
|---|---|---|
| Participant | Forms analogies and compares them with the problem as understood. | An occupation different from those of the other members. |
| Facilitator | Leads the session, proposes a mechanism and brings each analogy back to the problem as understood. | Extreme optimism, the widest possible experience, mastery of Synectics and enough distance to steer the session. |
| Specialist | Joins the group when feasibility has to be examined. Plays the encyclopedia or the devil's advocate. | Keeps the role of specialist. Translates the terms of the field into a language the whole group understands. |
| Client | Brings the problem and makes the group members available. | Management judges the group on its concepts, then on its models. |
The specialist can also form analogies with the group. Gordon gives the example of a biologist who proposes biological analogies for a problem in physics. The specialist's main role remains the comparison. The specialist knows the field of the problem and judges better than the others what an analogy brings to it. Gordon compares this role to that of a policeman who directs the traffic of associations towards the problem as understood. In the session he reports, nobody forces the chemist in the room to leave his role. The chemist does not feel threatened and takes an interest in the group's work.
Gordon's team trains the client's group for twelve months. The participants spend one week a month with the trainers and three weeks at their own jobs. At the end of the fourth month, the group presents its first concepts and viewpoints to management.
Running the session
The facilitator writes the problem as understood where the group can see it throughout the session. After each analogy, the facilitator asks what it says about this problem. Gordon describes an oscillation: the group forms an analogy that seems irrelevant, then compares it with the problem as understood.
To compare, the group carries the analogy's mechanism over to the problem. It inverts the mechanism where needed. In the flounder, the black pigment rises towards the skin. The roof reuses the mechanism with the colour reversed: the white beads rise to the surface. The facilitator and the specialist check whether the comparison yields a technical idea. If it does, the viewpoint is actual and the group analyses it. If not, the group continues with another analogy.
In training, the group works for an hour, then listens to the recording again. The trainers show where a mechanism was used and where one should have been. The sessions stop when an actual viewpoint appears. The group then moves on to the trial: it builds a model, examines the market or costs the principle. Gordon holds model building to be the most important and most underrated aspect of a Synectics project.
Gordon presents the method as a way of working harder. He observes complete fatigue in the participants at the end of a session.
The scope of the method
Gordon trains his groups on technical problems. Their solutions are easier to judge than the answers to a policy or financial question. His last chapter transcribes a session on a public policy question. Gordon presents this use as a possibility.
A measured trial verifies a principle for a process or a business rule: a pilot in one department, a prototype or an A/B test. Without a trial, the viewpoint remains the group's opinion.
Synectics after 1961
Gordon and Prince left Arthur D. Little in 1960 to found Synectics Inc. In his book, Gordon credits Prince with "the most important single advance" in the theory. Prince insisted on a method that trainees could understand.
In later versions of the method, a problem owner is named before the session. The problem owner judges how useful the ideas are. The role can pass to another person during the session. This role does not appear in the 1961 book. Vincent Nolan chaired Synectics Europe. In 2003 he described Synectics as a set of process tools. A group uses them separately or in the sequence of the original invention model.
AI considerations
During preparation, a language model proposes source domains for direct analogy: organisms that change colour, filter, close up or fold. It extends the list beyond the occupations present in the room. It sometimes invents the biology it cites. A false natural mechanism leads to a false principle. The specialist checks each biological fact against a source before the group compares it with the problem.
After the session, the facilitator reads an automatic transcript of the recording instead of replaying all of it. The facilitator marks in it where the group used a mechanism and where one was needed. Gordon did this work by listening to the tape again. Recording requires the consent of each participant. The facilitator submits a problem statement that contains customer data or trade secrets only to a service that the organisation has approved.
Personal analogy and fantasy analogy work only through the participants' own involvement. A model can write a participant's identification with an element of the problem. The participant who reads it does not go through the loss of control that Gordon describes. Nor does the model judge whether a viewpoint is actual. The domain specialist judges that.
Examples
The session record shows what each analogy yielded once compared with the problem as understood. It separates the potential viewpoint from the actual one. The case concerns access rights to the applications of a cantonal administration.
| Phase or mechanism | Content | Comparison with the problem as understood | Viewpoint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Problem as given | Reduce the six working days it currently takes to grant access rights. | ||
| Problem as understood | Grant a low-risk right on the same day without losing control of the rights granted. | ||
| Fantasy analogy | "The right opens when the person needs it and closes by itself when they no longer need it." | The right should know when it is no longer in use. Nobody knows how. | Potential |
| Direct analogy | The immune system tolerates what it knows and reacts to the anomaly. | Grant first, monitor afterwards. The security specialist points out that the identity management tool does not detect abnormal use. | Potential |
| Personal analogy | "I am the access right. They grant me after six days, then everyone forgets me. Nobody revokes me. I stay open for years." | Rights pile up because nobody revokes them. If the line manager does not confirm the right, the right should lapse. | Potential |
| Symbolic analogy | "A melting key." | The key melts on a date set in advance. The identity management tool already handles expiry dates. | Actual |
| Chosen viewpoint | A low-risk right is granted on the same day. It expires after 30 days if the line manager does not confirm it. | ||
| Planned trial | Two departments for six weeks. Measures: time to grant, share of rights confirmed, share of rights expired. | ||
The fantasy analogy expresses the wish. Only the symbolic analogy supplies the technical means. The other three stay in the record: the personal analogy brought out the accumulation that the end date corrects.
Visualizations
The diagram under Description shows the session loop and the return to the problem as understood. The mechanisms table and the roles table summarise how the session runs. The session record shows the deliverable of the example.
Cost
| Dimension | Level | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | High | Analyse the problem, bring together five to seven people from different occupations, find a trained facilitator and a specialist. Gordon's full model trains the group one week a month for twelve months. A one-off session needs at least a trained facilitator. |
| Execution | High | Repeated sessions until an actual viewpoint emerges, then a trial or a model. |
| Documentation | Medium | The recording, the session record and the planned trial. |
Tooling
A whiteboard or a flipchart shows the problem as understood in large letters throughout the session. An audio recorder captures the session. Gordon uses it to train the group, to recover viewpoints lost in the excitement of the session and to prove a concept's priority. After a session that has produced a concept, the members present sign a declaration of invention. The session record also serves to recover lost viewpoints. Where the organisation can file a patent, the recording and the signed declaration date the concept. Transcription software (Microsoft Teams, Zoom, Whisper) produces the text that the facilitator annotates. For a distributed group, an online whiteboard (Miro, Mural) replaces the flipchart. A spreadsheet holds the session record.
Sources
The procedure, the mechanisms and the roles come from Gordon's book. The other sources date the method's history and describe its later forms.
- William J. J. Gordon, Synectics: The Development of Creative Capacity, Harper & Row, 1961: the introduction for the name and the limit to technical problems; chapter 1 for the size of the group and the specialist's roles; chapter 2 for the two movements, the mechanisms and their examples; chapter 3 for the facilitator, the training and the replay; chapter 4 for the specialist in session; chapter 6 for the session on a public policy question; Appendix II, pp. 158-160, for the nine phases.
- George M. Prince, The Practice of Creativity: A Manual for Dynamic Group Problem Solving, Harper & Row, 1970: the preface for the early years at Arthur D. Little and the founding of Synectics Inc. in 1960.
- Barbara Kerr (ed.), Encyclopedia of Giftedness, Creativity, and Talent, SAGE, 2009, article "Synectics", pp. 860-862, DOI 10.4135/9781412971959.n374: the problem owner in later descriptions.
- Vincent Nolan, "Whatever Happened to Synectics?", Creativity and Innovation Management 12(1), 2003, pp. 24-27: present-day Synectics as a set of tools used separately or in sequence.
- Università degli Studi di Udine, Handbook of creativity techniques, "Synectics": the classroom version and the compressed conflict.

