Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Stakeholder wheel for the rollout of smart electricity meters by a municipal utility in the canton of Vaud. The centre holds the initiative. Three concentric rings show the distance to the project: "Delivers the project", "Directly affected" and "Distant from the project". Segments divide the rings by category. A line separates the internal segments (owners, management, employees) from the external segments (customers, suppliers, partners, regulators, competitors, outside any category). Each named group occupies the cell where its ring crosses its segment. The inner ring holds the utility's management and the network manager (Management), the meter fitters (Employees), the meter manufacturer and the vendor of the meter data management system (Suppliers), the communications network operator (Partners). The middle ring holds the meter readers and the customer service and billing department (Employees), tenant households, owners of detached houses, businesses and households with a solar installation (Customers), the property management agencies that give access to the meter rooms (Outside any category). The outer ring holds the municipal executive and the municipal council (Owners), the Federal Electricity Commission (ElCom) and the cantonal data protection authority (Regulators). The Competitors segment stays empty. The team has written the reason in it: households do not choose their grid operator.

Stakeholder Wheel

The stakeholder wheel is a stakeholder map drawn as concentric rings cut into segments. The rings show the distance to the project. The onion diagram measures the distance to the solution in the same way. The segments show the category. The usual set has eight categories: owners, management, employees, customers, suppliers, partners, regulators and competitors. The analyst goes through the segments one by one. In each one, the analyst names the groups and the people who can influence the initiative or who are affected by it, then places each group in its ring. The wheel produces a first inventory. The stakeholder list receives it. The stakeholder matrix ranks it.

Purpose

The stakeholder wheel identifies stakeholders by category and places them by distance to the project. It answers the question: which groups does the initiative affect and how far from the project do they stand? A category that yields no name forces the team to look for the forgotten group or to justify its absence. The deliverable is the filled wheel.

Usage

When to use it

  • Start of an initiative: draw up a first inventory in a workshop before opening the stakeholder list.
  • Existing list to check: review the list category by category and have every empty category justified.
  • Outward-facing change: a new customer channel, a change of supplier, a regulatory obligation. The external categories force the team to look outside the organisation.
  • Participants new to the method: eight categories and three rings make sense without training and take less than an hour to go through.
  • Remote workshop: the wheel fits on a shared whiteboard.

When not to use it

  • Mostly technical roles: operator, maintainer, neighbouring system. The organisational categories do not name them. Prefer the onion diagram, which arranges the roles around the solution.
  • Need to prioritise: the wheel does not rank the groups it finds. Move on to the stakeholder matrix.

Description

Rings and segments

The centre of the wheel holds the initiative and its scope. Three concentric rings surround it and show the distance to the project. The onion diagram measures the distance to the solution in the same way. Spokes divide these rings into one segment per category. Each named group goes in the cell where its ring crosses its segment.

Onion diagram

Onion diagramSolutioncustomers, suppliers,regulators, and others1234
  1. 1Solution delivery
  2. 2Affected organisational unit
  3. 3Organisation or enterprise
  4. 4Affected external stakeholders

Stakeholder wheel

Stakeholder wheelProject123OwnersManagementEmployeesCustomersSuppliersPartnersRegulatorsCompetitorsInternalExternal
  1. 1Delivers the project
  2. 2Directly affected
  3. 3Distant from the project
On the left, the onion diagram arranges the stakeholders in rings around the solution. Its two outer rings separate the organisation from the outside world. On the right, the wheel arranges the stakeholders around the project and divides its rings by category. Its two sides draw the distinction between internal and external.
  • Delivers the project: the inner ring holds those who build and deliver the solution, from the project team to the contracted supplier.
  • Directly affected: the middle ring holds those whose work or daily life changes at go-live.
  • Distant from the project: the outer ring holds those who set the framework, fund or oversee without a change to their daily life.

The BABOK onion diagram gives one ring to the organisation and another to external stakeholders. Its outer ring groups "customers, suppliers, regulators, and others". The wheel draws the distinction between internal and external in its segments. It needs only three rings.

The categories

A line divides the segments into two sides. The internal side gathers those who belong to the organisation. The external side gathers those who deal with it from outside.

  • Owners: those who own the organisation or answer for it. They are the shareholders of a company limited by shares, the members of a cooperative, the municipality or the canton for a public institution and the foundation board for a foundation.
  • Management: the executives who set the objectives, allocate the budget and make the trade-offs. The sponsor belongs here.
  • Employees: those whose work changes with the initiative. Employee representatives speak for them.
  • Customers: those who buy or use the services. The category almost always splits: private and business customers, current and target customers.
  • Suppliers: those who deliver goods, services or systems to the organisation.
  • Partners: those with whom the organisation produces its service under a cooperation agreement. A reseller, an operator that carries its data and an umbrella organisation are partners.
  • Regulators: the authorities that set or enforce the rules that apply to the initiative. A federal office, a cantonal authority and a sector supervisory body are regulators.
  • Competitors: the organisations that serve the same customers. Nobody consults or informs them. The wheel keeps them because their offer can push the initiative off course.

The category set follows the sector

Checklist 234 of the Chartered Management Institute (CMI) notes that different authors propose different category sets. It arranges its own set in a primary circle and a secondary circle.

The eight categories of the wheel against the CMI's two circles
Stakeholder wheelCMI Checklist 234
OwnersShareholders and investors (primary)
ManagementManagers (internal, in neither circle)
EmployeesEmployees (primary)
CustomersCustomers (primary)
SuppliersSuppliers (primary)
PartnersCommercial organisations: landlords, business partners, competitors (secondary)
RegulatorsGovernment (secondary); legal authorities: inspectors and regulators (secondary)
CompetitorsCommercial organisations: landlords, business partners, competitors (secondary)
No category of its ownMedia (secondary)
No category of its ownSocial groups (secondary)

The CMI checklist notes that the groups vary with the nature of the business: a public sector contractor might list government among its primary stakeholders. A public administration adds the media and associations. A hospital splits customers into patients, relatives and insurers.

Running the workshop

  1. Set the scope at the centre. The scope decides who is a stakeholder. A vague scope inflates every segment.
  2. Adjust the category set. Add the categories that the sector requires. Split those that group opposing interests.
  3. Go through each segment. Ask who in this category can influence the initiative or is affected by it. The internal categories come first: the sponsor, the organisation chart and the project mandate feed them.
  4. Name groups precisely. The team splits each category down to a group that it can reach and interview: "customers" becomes "tenant households in the municipality".
  5. Place each group in its ring. Ask whether the group delivers the project, whether its work or daily life changes at go-live or whether it stays distant from the project.
  6. Enter a dual role in two cells. A group that belongs to two categories or two rings holds two roles. The team enters it once per role, under the name of the role. The meter fitter who lives in the municipality counts among the fitters in the Employees segment and among the households in the Customers segment.
  7. Question the empty segments. An empty segment signals a forgotten group or a category that is irrelevant to this initiative. Ian Alexander makes the same observation about the role slots of his onion model: an empty slot can point to a forgotten stakeholder. The team writes in the segment why it stays empty.
  8. Read the wheel in both directions. A segment read from the centre to the edge shows how a category spreads across the rings. A ring read all the way round gathers the groups of all categories at the same distance.
  9. Ask who is missing. Every stakeholder found knows groups that the workshop does not know. The analyst asks "who else should we consult?" at every first interview.
  10. Transfer the result. The names go into the stakeholder list with their category and their ring. The analyst then positions them in the matrix by power and interest.

Pitfalls

The categories are generic. A role specific to the initiative fits no segment and goes unnoticed. The IT security department that approves every new application does a regulator's work. Yet it sits on the internal side, where the wheel places no regulator. After the last segment, the team asks who can block or delay the initiative without belonging to a category. The answer opens an "Outside any category" segment on the side where the group belongs: the internal side for the IT security department, the external side for a property management agency.

Distance passes for weight. A group in the inner ring seems to count more than a group in the outer ring. Yet a regulator placed on the outside can stop the project. In the same way, equally filled segments suggest categories of equal importance. The ranking belongs to the matrix.

The wheel ages. The stakeholders and their distance to the project change with the phases, reorganisations and changes of scope. The analyst reviews the wheel at each of these points.

What belongs to the neighbouring techniques

The onion diagram arranges around the solution the roles that the organisational categories do not name: operator, maintainer, neighbouring system.

The stakeholder list carries a "Category" attribute that makes the empty category visible. The wheel runs the same check in a workshop before the list exists.

AI considerations

A language model quickly proposes candidates per category for a given sector. It helps check that an empty segment is empty for a good reason: the question "which regulators affect an electricity distributor in Switzerland?" returns a list to verify. It knows neither the organisation chart nor the organisation's agreements. The roles specific to the initiative escape it as they escape the wheel.

The model can also invent an authority or a law. The analyst checks each proposed regulator against its official source before entering it. If the wheel names people, the analyst enters it only in a tool that the organisation authorises for personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP).

Examples

A municipal utility in the canton of Vaud replaces the households' electricity meters with smart meters.

Stakeholder wheel: Smart meters in a Vaud municipalityStakeholder wheel for the rollout of smart electricity meters by a municipal utility in the canton of Vaud. The centre holds the initiative. Three concentric rings show the distance to the project: "Delivers the project", "Directly affected" and "Distant from the project". Segments divide the rings by category. A line separates the internal segments (owners, management, employees) from the external segments (customers, suppliers, partners, regulators, competitors, outside any category). Each named group occupies the cell where its ring crosses its segment. The inner ring holds the utility's management and the network manager (Management), the meter fitters (Employees), the meter manufacturer and the vendor of the meter data management system (Suppliers), the communications network operator (Partners). The middle ring holds the meter readers and the customer service and billing department (Employees), tenant households, owners of detached houses, businesses and households with a solar installation (Customers), the property management agencies that give access to the meter rooms (Outside any category). The outer ring holds the municipal executive and the municipal council (Owners), the Federal Electricity Commission (ElCom) and the cantonal data protection authority (Regulators). The Competitors segment stays empty. The team has written the reason in it: households do not choose their grid operator.Smart metersMunicipal utilityMunicipalexecutiveandmunicipalcouncilUtility managementNetwork managerMeter fittersMeter readersCustomer service andbillingTenanthouseholdsOwners ofdetachedhousesBusinessesHouseholdswith a solarinstallationMetermanufacturerVendor of themeter datamanagementsystemCommunicationsnetwork operatorElComCantonal dataprotectionauthorityEmpty: householdsdo not choose their gridoperatorProperty managementagencies: access to themeter rooms123OwnersManagementEmployeesCustomersSuppliersPartnersRegulatorsCompetitorsOutside any categoryInternalExternal
  1. 1Delivers the project
  2. 2Directly affected
  3. 3Distant from the project
Smart meters Municipal utility

Delivers the project

Internal

  • Management Utility management
  • Management Network manager
  • Employees Meter fitters

External

  • Suppliers Meter manufacturer
  • Suppliers Vendor of the meter data management system
  • Partners Communications network operator

Directly affected

Internal

  • Employees Meter readers
  • Employees Customer service and billing

External

  • Customers Tenant households
  • Customers Owners of detached houses
  • Customers Businesses
  • Customers Households with a solar installation
  • Outside any category Property management agencies: access to the meter rooms

Distant from the project

Internal

  • Owners Municipal executive and municipal council

External

  • Regulators ElCom
  • Regulators Cantonal data protection authority
  • Competitors Empty: households do not choose their grid operator
The filled wheel for the rollout of smart meters. Each group occupies the cell where its ring crosses its segment. The middle ring gathers the groups that the meter installation affects directly. The Competitors segment stays empty. The team has written the reason in it. The "Outside any category" segment holds the property management agencies.

The middle ring gathers in three segments the groups that the meter installation affects: the meter readers and customer service (Employees), the households and businesses (Customers), the property management agencies (Outside any category). The outer ring holds the municipal council, which approves the project's funding.

The Competitors segment stays empty. The team has written the reason in it: households do not choose their grid operator. The property management agencies fit no category. Yet they hold the keys to the rooms where the meters are installed. The team opens an "Outside any category" segment for them on the external side. The CMI set gives them a place: its commercial organisations include landlords, whose buildings the agencies manage.

Visualisations

A heavier line separates the internal segments from the external segments. An empty segment is still drawn.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowSet the scope and adjust the category set to the sector.
ExecutionLowA one-hour workshop with the sponsor and two or three people who know the organisation.
DocumentationLowThe analyst reviews the wheel at each change of phase or scope and carries the differences into the stakeholder list.

Tooling

A sheet of paper or a whiteboard is enough in the room: three concentric circles, eight segments and sticky notes. Online whiteboards (Miro, Mural, FigJam) serve the remote workshop. They also keep the wheel when it has to outlive the session, which happens as soon as the analyst reviews it at each phase. A diagramming tool such as diagrams.net or a slide produces a clean copy of the deliverable. A template drawn once saves redrawing the rings and segments at every review.

A spreadsheet holds the wheel as one row per named group and two columns for the category and the ring. In this form it goes into the stakeholder list without re-keying.

Sources

Stakeholder Matrix
All techniques
Stakeholder+ Mapping