Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Constructed case. Top view of a sheet folded into four. Two dotted fold lines cross at the centre. A hand-drawn spiral starts from a dot at the centre. Each quarter carries a question: "What must we protect?", "What must we resist?", "What must we invent?" and "What must we let go of?". A physiotherapist has written two ideas by hand under each question. She has circled "The slots each therapist blocks", "Online booking that takes longer than a call", "A waiting list for cancelled slots", "The front desk's paper schedule" and "Confirmations sent by hand". The ideas "The SMS reminder the day before", "Double entry between calendar and billing" and "The link to the doctor's prescription" are not circled.

Spiral Journal

Spiral Journal is a meeting structure from Liberating Structures. Each participant folds a sheet into four and slowly draws a spiral outward from the centre. They then silently write answers to four prompts that the facilitator reads one after another. Each answer fills one quarter of the sheet. Each person circles one or two ideas per quarter and presents them in a pair or a trio. Finally, a few participants name the common themes in plenary. Fisher Qua and Anna Jackson drew on the cartoonist Lynda Barry to design the structure. The steps on the site add up to 18 to 19 minutes.

Goal

In Spiral Journal, each participant writes down alone and in silence what they think about a challenge or an opportunity before anyone speaks. A writing prompt is an open question or the start of a sentence that each person completes: "My bold ideas are…".

According to the authors' site, the structure focuses thinking and brings out new ideas. It gives quieter people a comfortable way to contribute. Once shared, the answers reveal patterns and new directions for the work. The site links the structure to the fifth of its ten principles: "Practice Self-Discovery in a Group". This principle calls for engaging the group as fully as possible in discovering its own solutions.

The session produces one sheet per participant and the common or divergent themes that the plenary has named. The "journal" is a single sheet that each person fills in during the session.

The business analyst uses it to open a workshop that brings together stakeholders from several departments. The analyst learns where the stakeholders' perceptions converge and where they diverge before the first discussion. You will find the other structures under Liberating Structures.

Usage

When to use it

  • Opening a cross-department workshop: each person writes before speaking, then the group sees its shared and divergent perceptions.
  • Meetings dominated by a few voices: each person writes before the loud voices speak.
  • Group rushing to a conclusion: the site uses it to slow a group down and make it reflect more deeply on a challenge.
  • After a long session that generated many ideas: the site places it after Ecocycle Planning or Critical Uncertainties.
  • System replacement or reorganisation: the site suggests adapting the prompts to a transition or a loss.
  • Online meeting: each person settles in after their previous meeting or task and writes on paper in front of their screen.

When not to use it

  • Decision expected from the session: the structure produces ideas and no decision. Have the group rank the ideas with 25/10 Crowd Sourcing.
  • Facts to establish about the current situation: the prompts collect perceptions. Establish the facts through document analysis or interviews.

Description

The elements of the structure

The authors describe each structure by its design elements: the structuring invitation, the space and materials, the distribution of participation, the group configuration and the sequence of steps with their timing. The structuring invitation of Spiral Journal sets a calm tone: "Before we jump into talking about our topic, let's take a few minutes to collect our thoughts. We are going to do a quiet activity to prepare for the work ahead."

Each participant receives a sheet and a pen or a pencil. The facilitator plans space for pairs and trios. They also prepare the prompts. The roles are the facilitator and the participants. Online, a technical host assists the facilitator. Everyone has the same opportunity to contribute. Participants work alone, then in pairs or trios, then as a whole group.

Preparing the prompts

The four prompts carry the whole content of the session. The site's page imposes none. It shows a sample sheet and suggests a variant. It asks the facilitator to adapt the prompts to the group's situation.

SetPrompts
Sample sheet on the site"My absurd ideas are…"
"My bold ideas are…"
"My common-sense ideas are…"
"My simple, inexpensive ideas are…"
The site's variant for finding other options for the work ahead"What must we protect?"
"What must we resist?"
"What must we invent?"
"What must we let go of?"
The two sets of prompts that the site's page gives.

In our view, a good prompt is one that a person can complete in the first person in two minutes. Before the session, the facilitator answers each of their own prompts in two minutes.

PromptWhat it draws outKept or discarded
"What do you think of the project?"An overall opinionDiscarded
"What I fear about the go-live is…"A list of ideasKept
"The advantages of the new tool are…"The answer that the prompt suggestsDiscarded
What each prompt draws out and how the facilitator sorts it.

The steps

  1. Introduction (1 min): the facilitator reads the structuring invitation and hands out the sheets.
  2. Spiral setup (1 to 2 min): each person folds their sheet in half twice. The folds mark out four equal quarters. Each person marks a dot at the centre and slowly draws a spiral outward with the lines close together.
  3. Writing (8 min): the facilitator reads a prompt. Each person answers it in one quarter of the sheet. The facilitator then reads a prompt for each of the other three quarters in the same way. The 8 minutes give each prompt two minutes, including the time to read it.
  4. Selecting ideas (2 min): each person rereads their sheet and circles one or two ideas in each quarter that stand out or surprise them.
  5. Sharing (3 min): participants form pairs or trios. Each person presents the ideas they circled.
  6. Whole-group sharing (3 min): everyone returns to plenary. A few people share a strong idea or a common theme.

The steps add up to 18 to 19 minutes. Individual work takes 11 to 12 of them. The facilitator chooses the quarter where the writing starts.

  1. 1 minIntroductionPlenary
  2. 1 to 2 minSpiralAlone
  3. 8 minWritingtwo minutes per promptAlone
  4. 2 min Selecting ideasAlone
  5. 3 minSharingIn pairs or trios
  6. 3 minWhole-group sharingPlenary
  7. 18 to 19 min
The steps of Spiral Journal. Individual work takes 11 to 12 of the 18 to 19 minutes. Only the circled ideas go on to the sharing in pairs or trios.

Drawing the spiral

The facilitator reminds the group that all spirals are perfect, whether neat or wobbly. They say it before anyone apologises for theirs. In our view, the spiral is a transition into writing.

Writing without filtering

The facilitator encourages each person to write down all their ideas without sorting or criticising them. The sorting comes at the next step. The facilitator does not interrupt, because the exercise demands concentration: they read the prompt, announce the time and fall silent. In one variant, gentle music plays while people draw the spiral.

In our view, in a group that mixes French-speaking and German-speaking Swiss, each person writes in their own language, since everyone keeps their own sheet. Only the circled ideas are spoken aloud.

Circling, then sharing

Selecting ideas links the solitary writing to the sharing. In three minutes, a pair or a trio hears only the circled ideas.

Online

According to the site, Spiral Journal works well to open an online meeting. It helps participants settle in after their previous meeting or task. The site sees it as a way to have people write by hand during an online meeting.

The facilitator pastes each prompt into the chat as they read it. Pairs and trios share in breakout rooms. In plenary, each person types their answer in the chat and sends it at the facilitator's signal. The site calls this mode Chatterfall.

After the session

The business analyst notes the themes of the whole-group sharing on a flipchart. Online, they save the chat. In our view, the analyst then classifies each theme. A theme that several people name in plenary becomes a candidate requirement that the analyst confirms in an interview. A theme that only one person names becomes a question for the next workshop. A theme that points to a group absent from the room tells the analyst whom to invite to the next workshop.

What makes Spiral Journal fail

Four prompts that are too similar fill the four quarters with the same ideas. Each set on the site looks at the subject from four angles.

A facilitator who skips the selection of ideas turns the sharing into reading aloud.

In our view, a person who knows that a manager will read their sheet sorts their ideas before writing them. So the facilitator announces before the writing that each person keeps their sheet.

A session that stops at the sharing in trios leaves the themes in the trios. The whole-group sharing makes them visible to everyone.

In our view, a member of senior management may take the spiral for a child's exercise and refuse to draw it. The facilitator goes back to the invitation: the spiral gives everyone a few minutes to collect their thoughts. The facilitator draws their own spiral in front of the group.

Spiral Journal in a string

The authors combine several Liberating Structures into a string.

Site pageStringPurpose
Spiral JournalSpiral Journal, then 15% SolutionsTurn the ideas into action
Spiral JournalWhat I Need From You, then Spiral Journal, then What, So What, Now What?Let thoughts settle
Spiral JournalEcocycle Planning or Critical Uncertainties, then Spiral JournalTake stock after a long session that generated many ideas or strategies
Conversation CaféConversation Café, then Spiral JournalDig into the ideas that emerge
Drawing TogetherDrawing Together with Future~Present, Spiral Journal and Nine WhysGo further in self-discovery
The strings in which the site places Spiral Journal and the purpose it gives them.

Origin

The site names the cartoonist Lynda Barry as its inspiration. In 2013, Barry ran a writing workshop at the Rhode Island School of Design. There she had participants draw a spiral on a blank page and keep its turns as tight as possible. According to her, this gesture brings the writer into the physical act of writing. She also had them divide a page into four sections and fill each one in a minute without thinking first.

AI considerations

Before the session, a language model suggests sets of four prompts for the group's situation. The facilitator gives it the subject and the stage of the workshop. They sort the suggestions like their own prompts: they keep those they can answer themselves in two minutes and discard those that suggest their answer.

For a group that mixes French-speaking and German-speaking Swiss, the model translates the prompts. A native German speaker checks that each translation stays open.

Nobody uses a model while participants write. The site links the structure to self-discovery. An idea that a model suggests in a quarter replaces the one the participant would have found.

After an online session, the chat holds the ideas from the whole-group sharing. The model groups them by theme for the business analyst's record. The analyst compares each group with what the plenary named and removes any theme that the model added. The chat carries the participants' names. These are personal data within the meaning of Art. 5 let. a of the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP, SR 235.1). The analyst removes the names before handing the text to an external AI service.

Examples

A regional hospital is replacing the appointment tool of its physiotherapy department. The business analyst opens the kick-off workshop with Spiral Journal and the four questions of the site's variant. The figure shows a physiotherapist's sheet after the selection of ideas.

What must we protect? The slots each therapist blocks The SMS reminder the day before
What must we resist? Online booking that takes longer than a call Double entry between calendar and billing
What must we invent? A waiting list for cancelled slots The link to the doctor's prescription
What must we let go of? The front desk's paper schedule Confirmations sent by hand
Constructed case. A physiotherapist's sheet at the kick-off workshop for the new appointment tool. She has circled the ideas that she presents to her trio.

The physiotherapist presents her circled ideas to her trio. In plenary, two participants from different trios name the waiting list for cancelled slots. The analyst records it as a candidate requirement.

Visualisations

One diagram shows a participant's sheet after the selection of ideas. A second places the six steps on a time axis with the group configuration. The sets of prompts, the sorting of prompts and the strings are tables.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowWrite and try out four prompts. Provide a sheet and a pen per person. Leave room for the trios.
ExecutionLow18 to 19 minutes according to the site's steps, in the room or online.
DocumentationLowA record of the themes that the analyst takes from the flipchart or the chat.

Tooling

In the room, each participant receives a blank sheet and a pen or a pencil. A screen or a flipchart displays the current prompt. A timer helps the facilitator keep to two minutes per prompt. A second flipchart collects the themes of the whole-group sharing. In the variant with music, a speaker plays it.

Remotely, a video conference with breakout rooms (Zoom, Microsoft Teams) hosts the sharing in pairs or trios. The meeting invitation asks everyone to have a sheet and a pen. The facilitator prepares the prompts in a text file to paste them into the chat.

Sources

Fisher Qua and Anna Jackson designed Spiral Journal within the Liberating Structures community. The Liberating Structures site publishes the structure under a Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 licence.

  • Spiral Journal, Liberating Structures: the full description of the structure and the sample sheet.
  • The LS Principles, Liberating Structures: the fifth principle and what it asks.
  • Conversation Cafe, Liberating Structures: Spiral Journal after the Conversation Café to dig into the ideas that emerge.
  • Drawing Together, Liberating Structures: Spiral Journal in a string aimed at self-discovery.
  • Lynda Barry Writing Workshop, Center for Arts & Language, Rhode Island School of Design: the spiral and the page in four sections from Lynda Barry's 2013 workshop.
  • Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP), SR 235.1, art. 5 let. a: the definition of personal data, which the chat contains.
Spikes
All techniques
Sprint Review