Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Network map of a constructed case: a public transport company introduces breakdown reporting on tablets in its maintenance workshops. Three nested zones. In the Core: Claire (Management), Marc and Inès (IT), Yves (Maintenance). In the Immediate Network: Hélène (Management), Paolo (Maintenance), Sylvie (Operations) and Jonas (IT). In the Periphery: Rui (Maintenance), Béatrice (Staff committee) and Nora (External). Solid lines link people who know each other. Hélène knows Claire, Yves and Nora. Paolo knows Yves and Rui. Sylvie knows Claire, Marc and Béatrice. Jonas knows Inès. Dashed lines mark the ties to create: Yves with Rui, Claire with Béatrice, Yves with Nora. Each dashed line closes a triangle with two solid lines. The triangle Paolo, Yves and Rui is highlighted. Béatrice carries the "can block" symbol and Hélène the "can boost" symbol. A legend assigns a colour to each of the six role types.

Social Network Webbing

Social Network Webbing is a workshop structure in which a working group draws the map of its relationships on a wall. On it, the group places its members, the people it knows and those it would like to involve in its work. It then draws the ties between them and decides whom to invite, how to work around blockages and who can speed up the work. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless designed it and describe it in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures (2013). It is one of the 33 original Liberating Structures. It takes about an hour.

Goal

Social Network Webbing is a network-mapping exercise that the group runs itself in a workshop. The authors call the working group that draws the map the core group.

According to the book, the structure shows the resources hidden in the group's relationships and the ways to reach them. The whole group sees them at once. The structure draws on informal and loose ties ("even your friends' friends' friend") to move the work forward without detailed planning or big investments. Each member extends the network without waiting for top-down assignments.

The structure produces a wall map and a list of actions. The map shows the holes in the network: a role type without a single sticky note or a department that nobody in the core group knows. The book also intends the structure to spread knowledge and innovations within the organisation and beyond it. The map then helps the group choose whom to reach first outside the team.

For the business analyst, the structure complements the stakeholder map. That map sorts people by role, influence and interest. Social Network Webbing shows who knows whom and names people whom the project has not yet involved. You will find the other structures under Liberating Structures.

Usage

When to use it

  • Launch of a change initiative: the core group identifies its supporters, the people to involve and those who can block.
  • A method or a tool to spread beyond the project team: the first users map their network to find the next ones.
  • Cross-functional work without line authority: the map shows which relationships can secure a collaboration that the organisation chart does not impose.
  • Expertise missing from the core group: the group places in the Periphery the people who hold it in the organisation or outside it.
  • An existing stakeholder map: add the informal ties and the people it does not name.
  • Distributed team: according to the site, the structure moves online with no major adjustments.

When not to use it

  • Core group without a shared purpose: clarify the purpose first with Nine Whys. Without it, nothing guides the choice of whom to invite.
  • Need for measured data on interactions: the map shows what the core group knows. Use a network analysis based on a survey instead.
  • A climate where naming an opponent exposes the person who names them: gather the blockages in individual interviews.

Description

The elements of the structure

The authors describe every structure through five design elements. For Social Network Webbing, their site publishes a revised version. It differs from the 2013 book in the invitation, the group configuration and the steps.

ElementAuthors' siteBook (2013)
Structuring invitationExpand the group's circle of influence: identify the roles, name the people who can contribute and prepare a plan to involve them in the workMap the core group's network and decide how to expand and strengthen it. Name the people the core group works with and those it wants to involve for their influence or expertise
Space and materialsA clear wall where people can move around, a large sheet of paper, sticky notes in eight colours and thick markers. Online, a virtual whiteboardA long wall covered with paper or with several flipchart sheets. Sticky notes of 5 by 5 cm in at least eight colours. Thick black markers
Participation distributionA facilitator and the participants. No minimum size. The whole core group is invited and everyone has an equal opportunity to contributeThe whole working or planning core group. Everyone has an equal opportunity to contribute
Group configuration1-2-4-All to list the roles (1-3-All online), then the whole group1-2-4-All to name the main groups in the network, then the whole group to name the people and build the map
Steps and time allocationEight steps that add up to 56 minutes (the site states "~55 min")Six steps that add up to 55 minutes (the book states "1 hr.")
The design elements of Social Network Webbing according to the authors' site and according to their 2013 book.

The map: core, immediate network and periphery

The site divides the paper into three nested zones. The Core occupies the centre and holds the members of the working group. The Immediate Network holds the people these members know. The Periphery holds the people who are missing or whom the group could involve. The book does not name the zones. It asks the group to place each person according to their degrees of separation from the core group members and to build the map "as a web with a core and periphery structure".

The authors say that June Holley inspired them and present her as a "network weaver". With Valdis Krebs, she describes the core-periphery network as the target state of a community network. In the core, strong ties link the main members. The periphery brings together newcomers, bridges to other communities and outside resources. Looser ties attach them to the core. According to Krebs and Holley, the periphery brings in the ideas and information that the network does not yet have. The core acts on them. The site asks the facilitator to point out that a person in the Periphery can bring information and skills that the core group lacks.

The legend and the names

Before placing the people, the group draws up a legend of the types of roles or groups present in the network. It assigns a sticky-note colour to each type. The site caps the legend at eight functions and the book at ten. According to both sources, the map becomes confusing beyond that.

The book asks the group to write people's names rather than their position or title, because in the last step the group invites a person.

The steps according to the site

  1. Intro (1 min): the facilitator states the invitation.
  2. Identify roles (10 min): each person works alone and lists all the roles that matter in the group's work. Pairs consolidate the lists, then groups of four do the same, as in 1-2-4-All. A few people share their list in plenary.
  3. Create a legend (3 min): the group settles on the role types and assigns a sticky-note colour to each.
  4. Map the core network (2 min): each person writes their name on a sticky note and places it in the Core zone.
  5. Expand the network (10 min): each person adds the people they know to the Immediate Network.
  6. Extend the network (10 min): the group adds to the Periphery the people who are missing or whom it could involve.
  7. Annotate and draw connections (5 min): the group answers three questions with symbols and lines. Who knows whom? Who has influence and expertise? Who knows someone who could move the work forward?
  8. Identify new connections (15 min): the group looks for triangles to close and marks the ties to create. Each person commits to inviting new people into the work, working around blockages and boosting progress.

The book's version

The group creates the legend (5 min), then places the names of the core group at the centre of the wall (5 min). It adds the active people it knows (10 min), then those it would like to involve (10 min). It steps back and connects the people by answering four questions (15 min). Finally, it designs its strategies (10 min).

The book's questions are: "Who knows whom? Who has influence and expertise? Who can block progress? Who can boost progress?" The site leaves out the blocking question. Yet its last step asks the group to work around blockages. The site adds the introduction, the role step, the three named zones and the triangles to close. It cuts the drawing of ties from 15 to 5 minutes and extends the last step from 10 to 15 minutes.

Authors' site: 56 min
Intro 1 min
Identify roles 10 min
Create a legend 3 min
Map the core network 2 min
Expand the network 10 min
Extend the network 10 min
Annotate and draw connections 5 min
Identify new connections 15 min
Create a legend 5 min
Map the core 5 min
People the group knows 10 min
People to involve 10 min
Connect the people 15 min
Strategies 10 min
2013 book: 55 min
Added by the site
The steps of Social Network Webbing according to the authors' site and according to the 2013 book on the same time scale. The site adds the intro and the role step. The drawing of ties goes from 15 minutes in the book to 5 minutes on the site. The last step goes from 10 to 15 minutes. The site's steps add up to 56 minutes and the book's to 55.

Closing triangles

The site calls the search for ties to create "closing triangles". The book does not use the term. Beth Kanter quotes the definition that Valdis Krebs gives. In an open triangle, one person knows two others who do not know each other. That person can introduce them to each other. The triangle is closed when all three people know each other.

On the map, an open triangle can be spotted by eye: two sticky notes linked to the same third note and not to each other. The group chooses a few triangles and decides who connects each pair. The book advises thinking small when the group weaves ties: a pair or a small interest group.

From the map to actions

In the last step, the book asks the group for strategies to invite and attract new people into its work, work around blockages and boost progress. A useful action names who acts, with whom and by when: "Yves asks Paolo to introduce him to Rui before the pilot starts."

Online

According to the site, the structure works on a virtual whiteboard with no major adjustments. A technical facilitator assists the facilitator. Online tools can draw network maps. The site advises starting small to avoid being overwhelmed by data. The book suggests mapping software for more detail and metrics.

Variations

According to the site, each participant can first draw their own network. The group then builds the shared map. The site also proposes questions on how ideas travel: "Who takes ideas across groups and up the hierarchy? Who do you go to with a tender idea or a hunch for a prototype?" The book and the site advise returning to the map often to note who has joined the work and how the network grows.

Stringing it together with other structures

SourceStringWhat it produces
Chapter 6 of the bookNine Whys, then Social Network Webbing, then 15% Solutions, then Troika ConsultingThe group's purpose, then the people and groups to attract, then what each person does right away to strengthen the network, then advice on how to do it
Field Guide in the bookSocial Network Webbing, then 15% Solutions, Design StoryBoards or 1-2-4-AllThe follow-up actions
Field Guide in the bookImpromptu Networking, then Social Network WebbingTies made during the session, then the network map
Authors' siteSocial Network Webbing, then Network Relationship PatternsPossible reconfigurations of the network
The structures that the authors place before and after Social Network Webbing and what each string produces.

In Chapter 7, the authors describe a three-hour session with twenty-five leaders. There they cut the structure down to 20 minutes. They ask: "Who are the people we need to attract to this initiative? Who are the people we need to start the work? Who can block and who can enable fast progress? Who are experts on the periphery of this social network we need to tap?" They add: "Make it real by naming names."

What makes Social Network Webbing fail

A map that copies the organisation chart shows what the group already knew. The site asks the facilitator to keep informal relationships in view as much as the organisation chart. The book encourages members to "dream BIG" when they name the people to involve. A periphery limited to the colleagues whom the core group meets every week reproduces the existing network.

When time runs short, the facilitator is tempted to cut the last step. The session then leaves a map without action. In our view, the facilitator shortens the network expansion instead and keeps the 10 to 15 minutes of the last step.

The map shows what the core group members know and believe about their network. A tie that nobody in the room knows about does not appear on it. A "can block" expresses one participant's opinion.

The map carries names and judgements about people. These are personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP). The sources do not mention this. In our view, the group takes the map off the wall after the session and keeps its photo for its own use.

What the authors report

Tim Jaasko-Fisher had seventy judges, lawyers, court clerks and child welfare social workers build a map of this kind. According to him, the map helped isolated people see the ties between the levels and functions of the court system. It showed them that they could succeed without authority over the whole process.

The Innovation Learning Network brings together healthcare organisations. Each member organisation has designated a "network weaver" who connects people with each other and with projects. According to the book, this role came out of the network mapping that its members carried out in 2006 and 2007.

AI considerations

After the session, the group needs a map that it can update. A language model that reads images transcribes the photo of the wall into a list: one line per person with their zone and role type, one line per tie. The facilitator does not send this photo to an external AI service, since it carries personal data. They use a model hosted within the organisation or transcribe the map themselves.

An external model can then write the script that processes this list. It needs only the column format and a few lines in which codes replace the names. The script draws the map in network software and lists the open triangles. The group chooses which ones to close. The script cannot tell whether an introduction makes sense.

Asked about the people who could support a project, a model invents plausible ties. Only the core group knows who knows whom. Only the core group can offer to introduce two people to each other and then do it.

Examples

In this constructed case, a regional public transport company introduces breakdown reporting on tablets in its maintenance workshops. The project's core group has four members. Its legend keeps six role types.

ClaireMarcInèsYvesHélènePaoloSylvieJonasRuiBéatriceNoraCoreImmediate NetworkPeripherycan boostcan block
Management
Maintenance
Operations
IT
Staff committee
External
Know each other
Tie to create
Constructed case. A regional public transport company introduces breakdown reporting on tablets in its maintenance workshops. The project's core group has four members. A solid line links two people who know each other. A dashed line marks a tie to create. Paolo knows Yves and Rui. By introducing Rui to Yves, he closes a triangle. In the same way, Sylvie can introduce Béatrice to Claire. Hélène can introduce Nora to Yves. Béatrice can block the project and Hélène can boost it.

The last step produces the action log.

PersonZoneKnown byActionGoal
Rui (mechanic and apprentice trainer)PeripheryPaoloYves asks Paolo to introduce him to Rui before the pilot starts. He invites Rui to the pilot.Invite
Béatrice (chair of the staff committee)PeripherySylvieClaire asks Sylvie to arrange a meeting with Béatrice before the project chooses which data the tablet records.Clear a blockage
Hélène (technical director)Immediate NetworkClaire and YvesClaire asks her to free up two hours per mechanic for the pilot.Boost
Nora (head of maintenance at another transport company)PeripheryHélèneYves asks Hélène to introduce him to Nora. He then visits the workshop that Nora has equipped with tablets.Boost
Constructed case. The action log decided in the last step. Each row names a person on the map, the core group member who acts and the goal of the action.

The actions for Rui, Béatrice and Nora each close a triangle: the person who knows the other two makes the introduction. No core group member knows Béatrice, who can block the project. The map shows that Sylvie knows her. Claire meets Béatrice through Sylvie before the project chooses the data.

Visualisations

A network map shows the three zones, the existing ties, a possible blocker and a supporter. Dashed lines on it mark the ties to create and the triangles they close. A timeline compares the steps and durations of the site and of the book. The elements of the two versions, the strings and the action log fit into rows and columns.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowBring the core group together around a shared purpose. Cover a wall with paper and provide sticky notes in eight colours.
ExecutionMediumOne hour with the whole core group. The book shows a 20-minute form.
DocumentationMediumPhotograph the map, transcribe it and update it when the network changes.

Tooling

In the room, the structure needs a long wall, paper on a roll or flipchart sheets, sticky notes in at least eight colours and thick black markers. Drawn symbols or coloured dots mark the people who can block or boost the work.

Remotely, a virtual whiteboard such as Miro or Mural replaces the wall. For a map that the group keeps up to date, network mapping software such as Kumu or Gephi draws the ties from a list and computes metrics.

Sources

Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless designed Social Network Webbing and name June Holley as their inspiration. The book is published under a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 3.0 licence. The structure's page on the site is published under a BY-SA 4.0 licence.

  • Henri Lipmanowicz, Keith McCandless, The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures: Simple Rules to Unleash a Culture of Innovation, 2013, ISBN 978-0-615-89337-2: the description of Social Network Webbing with its invitation, six steps, purposes, tips, variations and examples (Field Guide, Part Four); the strings (Chapter 6); the agenda for the twenty-five leaders (Chapter 7); the testimony of Tim Jaasko-Fisher and the Innovation Learning Network (Part Three).
  • Social Network Webbing, Liberating Structures: the site version with its invitation, its eight steps and their durations, the three zones of the map, closing triangles, online facilitation and the tips for the facilitator.
  • Valdis Krebs, June Holley, Building Smart Communities through Network Weaving, 2002-2006: the core-periphery network and the role of the periphery.
  • Beth Kanter, Close the Triangle, 2011: the definition of the open and the closed triangle that Valdis Krebs gives in "Network Weaving 101" (2006).
  • LS Menu, Liberating Structures: the 33 structures of the original repertoire.
Snaking the Drain
All techniques
Spaghetti Diagram