Shift & Share
Shift & Share is a Liberating Structures meeting structure. It shows a group several innovations that its own members developed. A few presenters each hold a station. The rest of the group splits into as many small groups as there are stations. The groups move from one station to the next at the same signal. At each station, the presenter explains their innovation in a few minutes and then answers questions. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless describe the structure in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures (2013). For six stations, the book allows about 90 minutes. The authors' site allows 70 to 90 minutes.
Goal
Shift & Share is a meeting structure in which a few people each present an innovation to small groups that come to each presenter's station in turn.
According to Lipmanowicz and McCandless, the structure replaces long plenary presentations with short talks that the presenters give at the same time to several small groups. The book intends it for innovations and useful programmes that may lie hidden in a group, an organisation or a community.
In a small group, everyone finds it easy to talk to the presenter. Participants learn where a new idea already works and how to adapt it to their own situation. The presenter learns by repeating the talk to each group. According to the book, the groups also spot ideas that are worth combining.
According to the book, the structure shows participants that they already innovate or that they can. It creates trust, a community of practice, friendly competition and collaborations among them.
The structure produces no decision and no document. Participants leave with what they have seen and the name of the person who does it. In our view, a business analyst uses it to take stock of the local solutions that already exist: a spreadsheet, a procedure, a workaround. The analyst records these solutions before describing the target solution. At each station, they note the practice, the tool, the person and the unit. These notes feed the analysis of the current state and the stakeholder list. Each presenter already runs a local solution. The target solution must therefore take that presenter into account.
You'll find the other structures in the repertoire under Liberating Structures.
Usage
When to use it
- New members of a network: show them the range of the community's innovations in one session. The book cites a research consortium.
- Merger of two organisations: present the programmes and the people of both former entities.
- Conference: place presenters from the field next to vendors who demonstrate technology applications.
- Innovations that management does not see: give the floor to frontline staff rather than to the owners of the official programmes.
- Start of an analysis: the people behind the local solutions present them before the analyst describes the target solution.
- Successful pilot in one unit: its authors show it to the units that will adopt it.
- Distributed team: the site provides an online version with breakout rooms.
- Before Wicked Questions: the book opens a string with Shift & Share to show the group's innovations.
When not to use it
- Fewer than ten participants: the site sets this minimum. In our view, each innovator then presents their work to the whole group.
- Fewer than three innovations to show: the book calls for 3 to 7 presenters. In our view, a presentation followed by a 1-2-4-All gets the whole room working on each one.
- A choice between the innovations: Shift & Share presents the innovations without ranking them. Compare the options in a decision matrix.
Description
The invitation
According to the book, the facilitator invites participants to visit several innovators. Each innovator shares something new that they are doing and that may be useful to the participants. The site compares this visit to speed dating for innovations.
Who presents
The book calls the presenters innovators. The word means anyone who does something new, whatever their position. To find them, the book advises digging into the informal networks beyond the names that everyone knows. The book puts content above presentation skills and charisma.
The book calls for 3 to 7 presenters. The facilitator names them in advance or gathers volunteers at the start of the session. In our view, asking managers for nominations brings in the owners of the well-known programmes. The facilitator instead asks each team which colleague has changed a way of working.
The room and the stations
The book asks for a large room with 5 to 8 stations. The stations stand far enough apart not to disturb each other. Each station gets chairs for a small group and space for a display if the presenter needs one. The site also asks for space between the groups so that each group hears its presenter.
Groups and roles
Each presenter sets up their station. The facilitator splits the other participants into as many small groups as there are presenters. A group stays the same for the whole rotation. According to the book, every member of a small group has the same chance to ask a question or give feedback.
The site distinguishes the host, the presenters and the audience. Online, a technical host manages the rooms.
The steps according to the book
- The facilitator explains the process: the groups move from station to station for a 10-minute presentation followed by a short period of questions. If this was not done in advance, the facilitator names the presenters and then forms as many groups as there are presenters (5 min).
- Each group goes to a different station. The presenter explains their innovation (10 min).
- Participants ask their questions or give feedback (2 min).
- At the signal, all the groups move to the next station (1 min).
- The groups repeat steps 2 to 4 until they have visited every station. Each presenter repeats their talk up to seven times.
The book allows about 90 minutes for six stations. Its own durations give 5 + 6 × (10 + 2) + 5 × 1 = 82 minutes: the introduction, six stations and five moves.
Timing by source
| Item | Book (2013) | Authors' site |
|---|---|---|
| Stated duration | About 90 min for 6 stations | 70 to 90 min |
| Stations | 5 to 8 | 5 to 8 stations and up to 7 rounds |
| Introduction | 5 min: process, presenters and groups | 1 min of introduction and 1 min of instructions |
| Presentation | 10 min | 5 to 7 min |
| Questions and feedback | 2 min | 3 to 4 min |
| Move | 1 min | 1 min |
| One round at a station | 12 min plus 1 min to move | 9 to 12 min including the move |
| Close | None | 2 min of sharing in plenary |
| Minimum number of participants | Not specified | 10 participants |
| Roles | Presenters and participants | Host, presenters and audience |
| Calculated total for 6 stations | 5 + 6 × 12 + 5 × 1 = 82 min | 1 + 1 + 6 × (9 to 12) + 2 = 58 to 76 min |
| Calculated total for 7 stations | 5 + 7 × 12 + 6 × 1 = 95 min | 1 + 1 + 7 × (9 to 12) + 2 = 67 to 88 min |
The book counts the moves between the stations. The site counts the move inside each round. According to the book, presenters are used to speaking for much longer than ten minutes. The site allows 5 to 7 minutes. Both settings come from the authors. In our view, the facilitator applies the durations of one source only.
Online
The book proposes chat rooms in which the groups choose a handful of sessions. The site splits the audience into breakout rooms. At each round the presenters change rooms and the audience stays. The presenters show their visuals by screen sharing or in a visual collaboration space. For a long session, the site advises a short break halfway through.
Preparing the presenters
The book advises preparing the presenters when possible. The site asks them to practise keeping to time.
According to the book, the presenter tells a story. It takes the audience from a small change in behaviour to a broader change in values or in the allocation of resources. The presenter brings examples and objects that participants can see and touch. The presenter entertains the audience and stirs its imagination.
In our view, twenty slides do not fit into ten minutes. A real form, a screenshot of the tool or the team's progress tracker shows in one minute what the presenter has changed.
Keeping time
The book and the site both ask the facilitator to keep strictly to the timing. The book suggests a loud sound or tingsha bells to announce each change of station. All the groups move at the same signal.
In our view, a presenter who overruns takes that time from each group's 2 minutes of questions. If the facilitator delays the signal, the whole rotation falls further behind at every round: 2 extra minutes at six stations add 12 minutes. A presenter who overruns in the first round overruns in every round. The facilitator therefore corrects them at the first change of station.
After the session
The book trusts the participants: those interested in an innovation go back to its author to learn more. The site adds a two-minute plenary in which a few people name an idea that inspired them.
In our view, the facilitator then hands out the list of stations with each presenter's name and contact details. A participant who wants to learn more knows whom to ask.
What makes Shift & Share fail
According to the book, the formal hierarchy can hide the contributions of frontline innovators.
In our view, groups that are too large also make the structure fail. The size of a group is the number of other participants divided by the number of presenters. With 70 participants including 6 presenters, the other 64 form groups of 10 or 11 people. The 2 minutes of questions then leave room for one or two questions. The easy contact that the book expects from a small group disappears. The facilitator switches to the site's durations, which allow 3 to 4 minutes of questions.
At a conference, the book places vendors next to presenters from the field. In our view, a vendor's station then turns into a sales pitch. The facilitator gives the vendors the same instruction as the other presenters: one use case and its result rather than a catalogue.
Variations
The book proposes these variations:
- The groups debrief what they experienced with What, So What, Now What?
- As at a PechaKucha Night, each station offers drinks and snacks.
- The presentation shrinks to 8 minutes.
- Without fixed groups, the structure combines with Open Space: everyone goes where their curiosity leads them.
- In a second round, a few stations stay open for impromptu presenters.
The site proposes shorter presentations to keep up the pace. It also proposes longer question periods to give the presenters more feedback. In person, it lets participants choose their stations.
Shift & Share in strings
| Source | String | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| Book (chapter 6) | Shift & Share, then Wicked Questions, then 1-2-4-All | Bring innovative activities into the open. Find the narrow path to more success. Sort the follow-up activities. |
| Book (Shift & Share) | Shift & Share, then Improv Prototyping | Generate variations on the ideas presented |
| Book (Improv Prototyping) | Improv Prototyping with Design StoryBoards, Shift & Share and User Experience Fishbowl | Spread the innovations |
| Book (Generative Relationships STAR) | Conversation Café, Shift & Share or What, So What, Now What? | Increase the diversity of viewpoints when the group scores low on "Separateness" |
| Site | Shift & Share, then Troika Consulting and Purpose-to-Practice | Refine the new ideas |
AI considerations
Neither the book nor the site mentions AI. In our view, it helps with preparing the session and with using what the session produced. It does not help with choosing the presenters.
A language model that searches the intranet, the annual reports or the organisation chart for innovators finds the people who already publish. The book asks the facilitator to look for innovators in the informal networks, which the model does not see. The facilitator asks the teams in person.
A spreadsheet or a model calculates the rotation plan and the time of each round. The facilitator checks the plan: each group sees each station once and no station receives two groups in the same round.
A presenter can ask a model to cut their notes down to ten minutes. They keep their own story: only they know the path from the small change in behaviour to the broader change that the book asks them to tell. In our view, a text polished by a model often loses the details that make people want to go back to the author.
In our view, the host of an online session turns off the automatic transcription of the video conference. A frontline innovator speaks less freely about a workaround when their talk is recorded.
After the session, a model can group the participants' notes by station. These notes often name colleagues. Names are personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection (Art. 5 let. a FADP). A facilitator who hands the notes to an external AI service first removes the names and the details that make a person recognisable: their role or their department.
Examples
Before the session, the facilitator writes the rotation plan with the book's durations. In this constructed case, two Vaud municipalities have just merged. Six staff members from the two former administrations each present one practice from their department to six groups. The introduction runs from 09:00 to 09:05.
| Station | Round 1 09:05 to 09:17 | Round 2 09:18 to 09:30 | Round 3 09:31 to 09:43 | Round 4 09:44 to 09:56 | Round 5 09:57 to 10:09 | Round 6 10:10 to 10:22 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Building permits filed online | A | F | E | D | C | B |
| 2. Waste collection round planned in a spreadsheet | B | A | F | E | D | C |
| 3. Welcoming new residents | C | B | A | F | E | D |
| 4. Booking municipal rooms | D | C | B | A | F | E |
| 5. Water meter readings on a tablet | E | D | C | B | A | F |
| 6. Apprentice supervision | F | E | D | C | B | A |
Each group moves to the next station. After station 6, it returns to station 1. Each row contains the six letters once: each presenter receives each group. Each column also contains them once: in each round, each group is at one station only. The presenter at station 3 gives their talk six times between 09:05 and 10:22.
Visualisations
A diagram shows the room from above with the stations, the groups and the direction of rotation. A second diagram contrasts presentations given in plenary with the stations of Shift & Share. Tables give the timing from both sources, the strings and the rotation plan.
Cost
| Phase | Level | Justification |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | Medium | Find the presenters in the informal networks and prepare them. Set up the stations far apart from each other. The book and the site ask for 5 to 8. |
| Execution | Medium | About 90 minutes according to the book, 70 to 90 minutes according to the site. Each presenter repeats their talk up to seven times. |
| Documentation | Low | The facilitator hands out the list of presenters and their contact details. |
Tooling
The room needs chairs set out for small groups. At each station, a table or a wall holds the presenter's objects and materials. A loud sound or tingsha bells announce each change of station. A timer that everyone can see helps the presenters keep to time. A spreadsheet is enough for the rotation plan.
Remotely, Zoom or Microsoft Teams split the audience into breakout rooms. The presenters show their visuals on an online whiteboard such as Miro or Mural.
Sources
Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless designed Shift & Share. According to the book, the structure draws on Chris McCarthy and the Innovation Learning Network.
- Henri Lipmanowicz, Keith McCandless, The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures: Simple Rules to Unleash a Culture of Innovation, 2013, ISBN 978-0-615-89337-2: the description of Shift & Share with its invitation, its steps, its purposes, its tips, its variations, its examples and its attribution; the string in chapter 6; the mentions in Improv Prototyping, User Experience Fishbowl and Generative Relationships STAR.
- Shift & Share, Liberating Structures: the site version with its durations, its roles, the minimum of ten participants, the online format, its variations and the string with Troika Consulting and Purpose-to-Practice.

