Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Diagram of Re-Sight. Three sources run across the top: field research results, desk research and notes from interviews with internal experts. In step 1, the team reads them through four lenses: the world, the market, the organisation and the end customer. In step 2, it records its findings on a sheet divided by a cross. The top left cell reads "Confirmed". The top right cell reads "Gaps". The bottom left cell reads "Discoveries". The bottom right cell reads "Hypotheses and ideas". In step 3, the right column leads to the research plan and the interview guide. The left column leads to the synthesis of insights.

Re-Sight

Re-Sight is a team exercise that takes stock of what an organisation already knows about a domain and its customers before it starts field research. The team shares out the existing studies, the desk research and the notes from interviews with colleagues who know the domain. It reads these sources through four lenses: the world, the market, the organisation and the end customer. It sorts its findings on a sheet with four cells: "Confirmed", "Discoveries", "Gaps" and "Hypotheses and ideas". The gaps and the hypotheses yield the research plan and the customer interview guide. Nathan Baird describes the tool in Innovator's Playbook (2020).

Goal

Re-Sight is a tool for reviewing existing knowledge. A team uses it at the start of an innovation project, before it commissions a study or interviews customers. Baird gives the review of existing knowledge three aims: establish what the team knows, establish what it does not know and frame the hypotheses it wants to test.

Baird rejects the habit of commissioning a new study at every project launch. The organisation often holds market studies and customer service reports. Colleagues there often know the customers. Re-Sight gathers this knowledge and names what is missing. From this argument Baird draws the rule that ends his chapter: new research targets the gaps that the review of existing knowledge found.

The tool delivers the research plan and the customer interview guide. These two documents set what the field research must cover and what it can leave aside.

Usage

When to use it

  • Launch of an innovation project: take stock of the knowledge before commissioning a study or planning interviews.
  • Customer studies in the archive: market studies, satisfaction surveys and customer service reports are waiting to be reread.
  • Team new to the domain: colleagues from other departments know the customers and agree to an interview.
  • Limited research budget: the customer interviews cover the gaps only.
  • Unchecked beliefs in the team: the "Hypotheses and ideas" cell makes them testable in interviews.
  • Team spread over several sites: each member reads their own sources before the team consolidates on an online whiteboard.

When not to use it

  • Domain with no existing knowledge: with no study to reread and no internal expert to interview, move on to observation and interviews.
  • Requirements to extract from documents: run a document analysis.

Description

Where the tool sits in Baird's method

Baird divides an innovation project into phases. His phase 2 is called discovery. It builds empathy for customers in three moves: the team reviews existing knowledge, runs new field research and then synthesises its observations. Re-Sight belongs to the first move.

Baird presents it as his second tool for this review. The first is a list of questions that he calls the "5Ws": who, when, where, why, what. These questions record what the team knows about the domain and where the gaps lie. Re-Sight starts from the sources: the team shares out the reading and sorts the findings on a sheet.

The sources to gather

Baird names three sources of existing knowledge. The first covers the research that the organisation has conducted on the domain and its customers: field research results and desk research. The second consists of interviews with internal experts. These are colleagues who know the domain. Baird calls them the "wise heads" (weise Köpfe in the German edition). He looks for them at every level and in every department. He adds the subject-matter experts on the topic of the project. The third is what the internet publishes on the domain.

A branch adviser who has served customers at the counter for fifteen years holds knowledge that no report records. In the chapter's takeaways, Baird extends the review to what the team knows about lost customers and non-customers.

The four lenses

The team reads each source from four angles that Baird calls lenses: the world, the market, the organisation and the end customer. Baird expects them to give an overall picture. The team agrees on the scope of each lens before the reading starts.

The four lenses of Re-Sight. Baird names them. Their scope and the typical sources are our reading.
LensWhat the team looks forTypical sources
The worldSocial trends, technology, regulation, demographics. A PESTLE analysis structures the reading.Industry reports, Federal Statistical Office figures, press
The marketCompetitors, offers, prices, sales channels, new entrantsMarket studies, competitors' websites, analyst reports
The organisationWhat the organisation has already tried, its capabilities, its constraints, its dataProject reviews, internal reports, interviews with internal experts
The end customerNeeds, behaviours, pain points, moments of use, lost customers and non-customersSatisfaction surveys, complaints, usage data, interviews with internal experts at the counter and in customer service

One source often feeds several lenses. We propose one sheet for every source and every lens. Each finding on it carries its lens. A finding in the left column also cites its source. A lens without findings becomes a gap.

The sheet

The Re-Sight sheet is a page that a cross divides into four cells. Baird gives a hand-drawn template of it. Each cell carries a title and an instruction.

  • Confirmed (top left; important existing knowledge in Baird's text): what the team already knows and what matters enough not to be forgotten.
  • Gaps (top right; knowledge gaps in Baird's text): what the team does not know and must still understand.
  • Discoveries (bottom left; new knowledge in Baird's text): new facts or insights.
  • Hypotheses and ideas (bottom right; first hunches and ideas in Baird's text): what the team would like to study further.

The cross separates two columns. On the left, "Confirmed" and "Discoveries" gather what the team holds. On the right, "Gaps" and "Hypotheses and ideas" gather what it must still find or check. The right column feeds the research plan and the interview guide. The left column later feeds the synthesis of insights. Baird makes that synthesis his phase 3.

Step 1
Field research results
Desk research
Notes from interviews with internal experts
The worldThe marketThe organisationThe end customer
Step 2
What the team holds
ConfirmedWhat the team already knows and must not forget
DiscoveriesNew facts or insights
Synthesis of insights (phase 3)
What it must find or check
GapsWhat the team does not know and must understand
Hypotheses and ideasWhat the team would like to study further
Step 3
Research plan and interview guide
The team reads the sources through four lenses. It then sorts its findings into the four cells. The right column yields the research plan and the interview guide. The left column feeds the synthesis of insights. Baird's template shows neither the sources nor the lenses.

The steps

The steps are Baird's. The facilitation guidance that goes with them is our reading.

  1. Gather and read. The team brings together the results of earlier field research, the desk research and the notes from the interviews with internal experts. It lists the sources with the title, date and owner of each. It then reads them through the four lenses.
  2. Share out the sources and record. The facilitator sets the sorting rule. A finding that the team already held and that a source establishes goes into "Confirmed". A sourced fact that the team did not know goes into "Discoveries". A belief without a source goes into "Hypotheses and ideas". The team then shares out the sources among its members. Each member sorts the findings from their sources into the four cells. The facilitator brings the team together and merges the notes on one shared sheet. Each reader presents their findings there. The team groups the duplicates and notes the contradictions between sources. A contradiction becomes a gap.
  3. Write the research plan and the interview guide. The team writes the research plan and the customer interview guide from the right column. According to Baird, the field research that follows closes the gaps, tests the hypotheses and builds empathy for the end customers.

From the right column to the interview guide

Baird defines the interview guide as the list of topics that the team wants to cover with the customer. He suggests that the team's market researcher, if it has one, take charge of the guide. The research plan allocates the field activities. Baird plans them in another table that he calls the Multiple Sources Framework. Before going into the field, the team frames the gaps in the guide and fills in this table. It splits its members into pairs and assigns each pair its task and its location. It then sets the date on which the team meets again to take stock.

Each gap becomes an open question in the guide or an activity in the plan. A team often closes a gap about behaviour better by observing than by asking. The plan then says who observes what, where and when. The customer cannot close some gaps, for example a gap on a tax rule. The plan assigns those gaps to desk research.

Each hypothesis and each idea becomes a stimulus that the interviewer puts to the customer. In Baird's method, the interview moves from broad to specific. The interviewer starts with the customer's life, moves to their product category (Baird takes finance as his example) and then to the subject under study. The stimuli come at the end. Baird compares the customer to a witness whom the interviewer must not lead.

A sheet often holds more gaps than one interview can cover. The team ranks the gaps by how much each one bears on the project decision. The gaps at the bottom of the list stay on the sheet.

Pitfalls

The overloaded "Confirmed" cell. A team often puts everything it believes into this cell. The guide then loses the questions that would have contradicted those beliefs. Each finding in the cell cites its source. A finding without a source moves to "Hypotheses and ideas".

Stale knowledge. An old study describes customers who have changed. A finding drawn from an old source goes into "Hypotheses and ideas" until a recent fact establishes it.

Forgotten internal experts. A team in a hurry reads the reports and skips the internal interviews. It loses the knowledge that staff never wrote down: the complaints repeated at the counter, the abandoned projects and the reasons for dropping them.

The gap framed as a closed question. "Do apprentices want a savings app?" invites a polite yes. The team writes the gap as a lack of knowledge: "how apprentices split their pay". It draws an open question from it. Baird lists open questions among his interviewing tips.

The abandoned left column. Once the guide is written, the team files the sheet away. It then runs the synthesis without its discoveries. The facilitator keeps the sheet with the field notes and brings it out again for the synthesis of insights.

AI considerations

A language model speeds up the first reading. It summarises an eighty-page study report and proposes findings sorted by lens and by cell. It spots the contradictions between two studies. From the gaps, it drafts a first version of the interview guide. It rewrites a closed question as an open one.

The model does not tell an established fact from a claim. It can file a claim from a sales brochure among the facts on the same footing as a survey result. The reader checks each finding against its source and its date before placing it in "Confirmed". The model has no access to the unwritten knowledge of internal experts. The team conducts the internal interviews itself.

Customer studies and the notes from internal interviews contain personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection. The team submits them to a service that the organisation has approved. Before using any other service, it removes the names and the details that identify the people quoted.

Examples

The example shows how the right column of a team sheet becomes the interview guide and the research plan. A cantonal bank is preparing a savings offer for apprentices. Its team has read the youth banking unit's report, a project review and the websites of two competitors. It has interviewed a branch adviser.

What the team holds
Confirmed
OrganisationHalf of all youth accounts are emptied in the year after the Federal VET Diploma.Source: youth banking unit report
CustomerMost apprentices receive their pay into an account that their parents opened.Source: interview with a branch adviser
MarketTwo competitors offer apprentices a fee-free account.Source: competitors' websites
Discoveries
OrganisationThe youth banking unit stopped a digital piggy bank after six months.Source: project review
CustomerSecond-year apprentices ask at the counter how to fill in their first tax return.Source: interview with a branch adviser
What it must find or check
Gaps
CustomerHow apprentices split their pay between spending, saving and family
CustomerWhy accounts are emptied after the VET diploma
MarketWhere apprentices keep their money outside the bank
WorldEmpty lens: no source on the tax treatment of apprentices' savings
Hypotheses and ideas
CustomerHypothesis: apprentices save for a specific goal (driving licence, travel).
OrganisationIdea: offer a savings transfer on payday.
Team sheet of a cantonal bank that is preparing a savings offer for apprentices. Each finding carries its lens. The findings in the left column also cite their source. Invented example.
From finding to entry in the guide or the research plan. Invented example.
CellFindingEntryTiming
GapsHow pay is splitGuide: "Tell me what you did with your last month's pay."Start of the interview
GapsAccounts emptied after the Federal VET DiplomaGuide (VET diploma holders who emptied their youth account): "Tell me what you did with your account after your diploma."Middle of the interview
GapsMoney kept elsewhereGuide: "In which banks or apps do you keep your money?"Middle of the interview
GapsTax treatment of apprentices' savingsPlan: desk research in the guidelines of the cantonal tax administrationOutside the interview
Hypotheses and ideasSaving for a specific goalGuide: cards "driving licence", "travel" and "no goal" shown to the apprentice, then "Which one sounds like you?"End of the interview
Hypotheses and ideasSavings transfer on paydayGuide: mock-up shown to the apprentice, then "What would you do with it?"End of the interview

Visualisations

The diagram of the sheet traces the sources through the lenses to the four cells and on to the two destinations of the columns. The lens table proposes the scope of each lens. The cantonal bank's filled-in sheet shows a team result. Each finding on it carries its lens. The findings in the left column also cite their source. The example table shows how the right column becomes the guide and the plan.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationMediumFinding the studies in the archives and conducting the interviews with internal experts.
ExecutionMediumEach member reads a share of the sources. The team then holds one joint consolidation session.
DocumentationLowOne team sheet, one research plan and one interview guide.

Tooling

In a meeting room, an A3 sheet or a whiteboard divided by a cross is enough. Coloured sticky notes mark the lens of each finding. A distributed team works on an online whiteboard (Miro, Mural). A spreadsheet holds the inventory of sources with their date, their owner and their reader. The team writes the interview guide in a shared document that the interviewers take into the field.

Sources

  • Nathan Baird, Innovator's Playbook: Produkte und Dienstleistungen entwickeln, die Kunden lieben, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2021, ISBN 978-3-527-51060-3. Translation of Innovator's Playbook: How to Create Great Products, Services & Experiences that your Customers Will Love, John Wiley & Sons Australia, 2020, ISBN 978-0-7303-8364-2. Phase 2 "Entdeckung", section "1. Prüfung des vorhandenen Wissens", pp. 42-43 and figure 2.1: the tool, the three sources, the four lenses, the four cells of the template and the three steps. Same chapter: the "5Ws", the Multiple Sources Framework, the interviewing tips and the takeaways.

The scope of the lenses, the facilitation guidance, the routing of gaps to observation or desk research, the ranking of gaps, the pitfalls and the cantonal bank example are our proposals. Baird's terms are translated from the German edition.

Ranking
All techniques
Real Options