Panarchy
Panarchy is a meeting structure from the Liberating Structures. A group draws the nested levels that range from the individual to the culture of a society and that bear on the spread of an innovation. On an Ecocycle loop, it marks the state of each level's response to the problem. It then looks for the obstacles and opportunities that pass from one level to another and decides a first action for each. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless describe the structure in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures (2013). They adapted it from the work of Frances Westley. A session lasts about two hours.
Goal
Panarchy helps a group find the level at which an innovation stalls and the neighbouring level through which it can pass. According to the authors' site, the lower levels change fast and the upper levels slowly. A local innovation can move up to the levels that conserve it. What the upper levels have accumulated can come back down to the lower ones.
According to the book, participants see how systems are embedded in one another. They understand how these interdependencies slow a change down or carry it. They spot the small changes that move an idea up to the higher levels. They learn that a shift at a larger or smaller level can release resources for their own. The group thus creates "opportunity windows" through which an innovation crosses levels and boundaries.
The structure produces the chart of levels. The chart carries the state of each level on the Ecocycle loop, the obstacles and opportunities between levels and a first action for each.
The business analyst uses it when a solution that works in one department has to spread to other departments, to other organisations or to a regulatory level. The chart complements the stakeholder map: it shows the level at which the spread stalls and the people who connect two levels. You'll find the other structures in the repertoire under Liberating Structures.
Usage
When to use it
- An innovation succeeds in one unit and does not spread: find the level where it stalls.
- A local solution does not scale up to the regional or national level: look for the windows open at the higher levels.
- Local units work around or ignore a standard: find the levels where the standard does not fit.
- The problem depends on levels outside the group's control: the canton, the industry or the regulator go on the chart.
- The group brings together several levels of the organisation: according to the site, the structure works best with eight people or more.
- An Ecocycle Planning session for the organisation needs a follow-up: Panarchy extends the assessment to the other levels.
- The spread depends on intermediaries: the first-actions step names the people who have influence at several levels.
- Distributed team: according to the site, the structure works online almost unchanged.
- A single person is stuck: ask the individual variation's questions about the levels and their speeds.
When not to use it
- The problem stays within one level: sort the group's activities with Ecocycle Planning.
- There is no idea or innovation to spread: first discover the local solutions with Discovery & Action Dialogue.
Description
The nested levels
The chart of levels stacks systems. The levels run from the smallest to the largest. The book sorts the factors into three tiers. The micro tier gathers particles, people and teams. The meso tier gathers organisations and networks. The macro tier gathers culture, politics and myths.
The book's worksheet draws six levels as a staircase, from the smallest at the bottom left to the largest at the top right. Each level has its own Ecocycle loop. According to the book, four to seven levels are enough.
- fast
- IndividualMicro
- TeamMicro
- Push from below
- OrganisationMeso
- NetworkMeso
- Window opening above
- PoliticsMacro
- Resources flowing down
- Culture and mythsMacro
- slow
According to the site, the lower levels change fast and the upper levels slowly. The book's individual variation asks how fast change happens at each level.
The elements of the structure
The authors describe each structure by five design elements. The site revises the version in the 2013 book.
| Element | Book (2013) | Authors' site |
|---|---|---|
| Structuring invitation | Identify what contributes to the problem at the levels above and below the participants. Name strategies and opportunities for change within each level and across several levels | "Let's zoom in and zoom out, exploring the levels of our world like Russian nesting dolls" |
| Space and materials | A clear flat wall with room to stand in front of it. A large Panarchy chart on a poster or flipchart. A blank chart per participant. Sticky notes | The same materials and tables of four |
| Distribution of participation | Everyone involved in spreading the innovation. Everyone has the same chance to contribute | The same people. No minimum size. The structure works best with eight people or more from several levels of the organisation |
| Group configuration | 1-2-4-All for all or most of the steps | 1-2-4-All. Three or four people from different groups build the shared chart while the others watch without interrupting |
| Level speeds | Not described | Fast at the bottom and slow at the top. The facilitator stresses this from the introduction |
| Ecocycle assessment | Steps 8 and 9 of the sequence | Optional variation of 30 to 50 minutes |
| Prioritisation | The group ranks the obstacles and opportunities | The group votes for the three most important obstacles or opportunities |
| Duration | 2 hours stated. The fourteen steps total 145 min | Thirteen steps in 130 min. The 10-min break after the plenary is one of them |
| Close | Revisit and update the chart as the spread continues | A 5-min step in which groups of three decide when to revise the chart |
| Online | Not described | Same sequence. The facilitator moves between the main room and the breakout rooms more often because the small groups are hard to observe |
On the site, three or four people build the shared chart in front of the room. The rest of the room watches without interrupting. The principle resembles the Fishbowl.
Preparing the session
The facilitator chooses a problem that needs coordination across several scales. A problem that one team can settle does not fill the chart.
The book invites everyone involved in the spread. It asks for people or perspectives from each level: the more participants, the better. When nobody knows a level, the facilitator researches it before the session. The site gives the example of education, where each level works differently. In Switzerland these levels are the school, the school group, the canton and the Swiss Conference of Cantonal Ministers of Education (EDK). The book also asks the group to take account of history, which defines what is possible at each level.
According to the site, participants benefit from knowing Ecocycle Planning before the session. The facilitator prepares a blank chart per participant and a large chart on the wall.
The sequence in the book
The book runs most of the steps in 1-2-4-All: each person alone, then in pairs, then in fours, then the whole group.
- Introduction (5 min): the facilitator presents Panarchy and, if needed, the Ecocycle. They show an example of a completed chart and hand a blank chart to each person.
- List the factors (5 min): each person answers the question "What are the smallest-to-the-largest factors influencing your/our chances for success?" alone. They look for micro, meso and macro factors.
- Define the levels (10 min): in pairs, participants translate the factors into levels and name each level.
- Compare the levels (10 min): the groups of four compare their levels and finish their chart with sticky notes.
- Merge the charts (10 min): each group of four adds to the large chart the levels that are not on it yet.
- Examine the attention received (10 min): the groups of four ask themselves "On which levels have attention and resources been invested to date? Which levels have been neglected? What do I/we know about the status and dynamics in play at the different levels?"
- Share (5 min): a few groups share their reflections with the room.
- Assess a level (15 min): each group of two or four takes one level and places it on the Ecocycle loop. The facilitator puts the people who know that level into each group.
- Present the assessments (10 min): each group briefly presents the state of its level.
- List the obstacles and opportunities (15 min): the small groups look up and down the chart. The book tells them to "go wild and have fun".
- Prioritise (10 min): the group ranks the obstacles and opportunities.
- Decide the first actions (10 min): in 1-2-4, the group gives each obstacle and each opportunity one first action.
- Place the first actions (15 min): the whole group sticks the first actions on their level of the large chart.
- Make sense of the chart (15 min): the group examines the chart with What, So What, Now What? and prioritises the next steps.
The entry's title states two hours. The step durations total 145 minutes. The book adds an instruction with no duration: revisit and update the chart as the spread continues.
- Drawing and examining the levels
- 1Introduction
- 2Factors
- 3Levels
- 4Comparison
- 5Merging the charts
- 6Attention received
- 7Sharing
- Assessing
- 8Assessing a level
- 9Presentations
- Acting between the levels
- 10Obstacles and opportunities
- 11Prioritising
- 12First actions
- 13Placing on the chart
- 14What, So What, Now What?
- Drawing and examining the levels55 min
- 1Introduction5 minWhole group
- 2Factors5 minAlone
- 3Levels10 minIn pairs
- 4Comparison10 minGroups of four
- 5Merging the charts10 minGroups of four
- 6Attention received10 minGroups of four
- 7Sharing5 minWhole group
- Assessing25 min
- 8Assessing a level15 minPairs or fours
- 9Presentations10 minWhole group
- Acting between the levels65 min
- 10Obstacles and opportunities15 minSmall groups
- 11Prioritising10 minNot specified
- 12First actions10 min1-2-4
- 13Placing on the chart15 minWhole group
- 14What, So What, Now What?15 minWhole group
- Whole group
- Alone
- In pairs
- Groups of four
- Pairs or fours
- Small groups
- 1-2-4
- Not specified
Assessing each level with the Ecocycle
The Ecocycle is a loop shaped like a horizontal figure eight. It carries four phases: birth, maturity, creative destruction and renewal. Ecocycle Planning places all the activities of an organisation on it. Panarchy places a single point per level: the state of the response to the problem at that level.
At step 8, the book asks the group what is going on right now at the level under study and which actions there address the problem. The group then says whether this response is in an entrepreneurial (birth), management (maturity), heretical (creative destruction) or renewal phase.
The two Ecocycle traps also apply to a level. The rigidity trap holds a level that keeps its practices out of habit. The scarcity trap holds a level where new ideas do not get the means to start. The 2013 book calls it the poverty trap.
In the book's example, an American project places a point on the loop of each level. The project prevents infections with methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). Experts from each level assess its state. The lowest level is the bacterium. The highest is public perception, which holds the infection to be inevitable. The book marks three traps on the chart and puts a question mark after each. The industry and public perception are in the rigidity trap. The pilot hospitals are in the poverty trap.
Looking for windows between the levels
At step 10, the small groups look for what passes from one level to another. The book asks them these questions:
- Which windows for new ideas are opening at the levels above?
- Which resources are flowing down from the creative destruction unfolding above?
- Which developments at the lower levels are disrupting the level above?
A window often opens when a higher level enters creative destruction. A law comes up for revision, a cantonal platform is replaced, the leadership changes. The resources that this level releases can then carry the innovation of the level below.
At step 12, each first action answers the book's questions: "What action can you take immediately to influence levels above and below you?" and "Who do you know that has influence in more than one level simultaneously?" Spotting these people is one of the purposes the book gives the structure.
After the session
The book asks the group to revisit the chart and update it as the spread continues. According to the book, the group prepares for serendipity "as opportunity windows open or close".
The business analyst carries the first actions over into the action plan with an owner and a date. An obstacle at a higher level goes into the risk register. The people who connect two levels go into the stakeholder analysis. At the next review, the chart shows whether the innovation has crossed the level where it stalled.
Variations
For a single person, the book asks these questions: "What is contributing to the existence of your challenge at levels above and levels below you? What elements are perpetuating the challenge you are facing? What are the different speeds for effecting changes at each of the levels?"
The site makes the Ecocycle assessment a variation that adds 30 to 50 minutes. In our view, the group should keep it whenever it is unsure at which level to act. It shows which level is frozen and which one is looking for ideas.
What makes Panarchy fail
A chart that stops at the boundaries of the organisation ignores politics and culture. The book asks for macro factors. In its example, the highest level is in the rigidity trap. The facilitator checks that at least one level reaches beyond the organisation.
A group that does not translate its factors at step 3 puts "the budget" or "resistance to change" on the chart as levels. A level is a system: a team, a department, a canton.
The book keeps 1-2-4-All for almost every step, "even if it feels like a chore". The aim is to find all the opportunities and obstacles at all levels. A group that goes straight to the plenary mostly collects the levels known to the people who talk most.
A group from a single level describes the others by hearsay.
A first action that stays at the group's own level spreads nothing. The facilitator sends back to the group any first action that touches no other level.
A window closes when a budget is passed or a law revision is completed. A chart that nobody revisits describes windows that have already closed. The group sets the review date before leaving the room.
Panarchy in a string
The authors combine several Liberating Structures into a string. Chapter 6 of the book places the strings that contain Panarchy under the goal of spreading an innovation out to other units and up to higher levels.
| String | Role of each structure |
|---|---|
| Nine Whys + Min Specs + Ecocycle Planning + Panarchy | Nine Whys clarifies with the community what justifies the work. Min Specs sets what must be done and what must be avoided. Ecocycle Planning places the activities and relationships at the level of the organisation. Panarchy does the same at the other levels and finds the possible actions. |
| Discovery & Action Dialogue + 1-2-4-All + Panarchy + Design StoryBoards | The DADs discover hidden solutions to a chronic problem. 1-2-4-All has each person decide how to adapt them to their context. Panarchy looks for ways to extend the success to the other levels. Design StoryBoards sketches the paths of coordination upward, downward and outward. |
The Panarchy entry also names Ecocycle Planning, 1-2-4-All, What I Need From You, Social Network Webbing and Celebrity Interview as structures to string with it. The site suggests What I Need From You or Social Network Webbing when the chart shows that the group needs more people at several levels. Finally, in the Agreement-Certainty Matrix entry, the book lists Panarchy among the structures that develop a strategy. The others are Critical Uncertainties, Purpose-To-Practice, Ecocycle Planning, Integrated~Autonomy and Discovery & Action Dialogue.
Origin
According to the book, the authors adapted Panarchy from the work of Professor Frances Westley. The book refers to Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems. This edited volume by Lance H. Gunderson and C. S. Holling appeared in 2002. The steps of the structure are those of Lipmanowicz and McCandless.
The word comes from ecology. Holling (2001) defines a panarchy as "a representation of a hierarchy as a nested set of adaptive cycles". The name joins the hierarchy of scales to the god Pan, whom Holling takes as the symbol of unpredictable change. For Holling, a hierarchy is a set of semi-autonomous levels that each change at their own speed. He rejects the reading of hierarchy as top-down control.
Holling names two links between the levels. Through "revolt", a crisis at a small and fast level spreads to a larger and slower level. It does so mostly when that level is in its conservation phase (the maturity of the Ecocycle). Through "remember", the renewal that follows a release phase (creative destruction) draws on what the larger and slower level has accumulated. The Liberating Structures do not use these words. On the authors' site, small experiments at the fast levels can move up to the slow levels that conserve successful innovations. The knowledge accumulated at the top can come back down and stabilise the lower levels.
AI considerations
A language model suggests a first list of levels for a domain. For a Swiss municipal project, it names the municipality, the regional association, the canton, the Confederation and the umbrella associations. The facilitator keeps this list for the end of step 5. The group then looks in it for the levels it has forgotten.
The model also summarises the state of a level that nobody in the room knows: a law revision in the consultation procedure, a federal programme, an industry standard. This summary gives the facilitator a starting point for the research that the book asks for on unfamiliar levels. A model can invent dates and legal articles. The facilitator therefore checks each fact against an official source before the session.
Assessing a level on the loop stays with the people who have experience of it: the book entrusts it to them. The model does not know who in the organisation has influence at two levels at once.
After the session, the model transcribes the photos of the chart and groups the duplicate sticky notes. The group rereads the transcription before it enters the action plan. The names of the people who connect two levels are personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP). The facilitator gives them only to an AI service approved by the facilitator's organisation.
Examples
A municipality in the canton of Vaud has put its event permit application online. The municipal clerk's office invites two local associations and draws the chart from its own level. The deliverable is the completed chart of levels. The chart marks the state of each level on the Ecocycle loop. The first actions target the levels above and below the group.
- Local associationsBirth30 of 45 applications online this year
- Municipal clerk's officeThe groupMaturityProcessing in 3 days instead of 10
- Municipal administrationScarcity trapPolice and roads department receive a printed file
- Municipalities of the districtRenewalThree municipalities ask for the form
- CantonRigidity trapHandwritten signature above 1'000 participants
- Administrative cultureMaturityEach municipality has its own forms
| Level | Obstacle or opportunity | First action |
|---|---|---|
| Canton | Opportunity: the canton replaces its online portal in 2027 and is looking for pilot municipalities | The municipal secretary puts the municipality forward as a pilot before 31 March |
| Canton | Obstacle: the cantonal form requires a handwritten signature above 1'000 participants | The clerk's office sends the cantonal department the record of the 30 online applications processed without incident |
| Municipalities of the district | Opportunity: three neighbouring municipalities ask for the form | The mayor sits on the committee of the regional association. He presents the pilot at the May meeting |
| Municipal administration | Obstacle: the municipal police and the roads department still receive a printed file | The business analyst estimates the cost of sending the file automatically for the 2027 budget |
| Local associations | Obstacle: 15 of the 45 associations still submit their application on paper | The clerk's office sends the 15 associations the link to the form with the confirmation of their last application |
The clerk's office and 30 of the 45 local associations have adopted the form. The spread stalls mainly above them. The municipal administration lacks the means to connect its departments. The mayor connects the municipality and the region: the regional first action goes through him.
The canton holds on to its handwritten signature. On its loop, it is in the rigidity trap just before creative destruction. In 2027 it replaces its online portal: the municipal secretary's first action targets this window. One level is thus in a trap and offers an opportunity.
Visualisations
A diagram shows the nested levels and the three crossings from one level to another. A second diagram places the fourteen steps of the book on a time axis with the group configuration. A third diagram shows the completed chart of the example. The comparison of the versions, the strings and the first actions are tables.
Cost
| Phase | Level | Justification |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | Medium | Choose the problem, invite people from each level, research the unfamiliar levels, prepare the large chart and the blank charts. |
| Execution | High | A large group from several levels meets for 145 minutes according to the book's steps. The site gives 130 minutes. With the Ecocycle assessment, the session lasts 160 to 180 minutes. |
| Documentation | Medium | Photograph the chart, transcribe the first actions with an owner and a date, update the chart at each review. |
Tooling
In the room, a clear flat wall holds the large chart of levels on a poster or on flipchart sheets. Each participant receives a printed blank chart. Sticky notes carry the levels, then the first actions. A visible timer paces the fourteen steps.
Remotely, a video conference with breakout rooms (Zoom, Microsoft Teams) replaces the tables of four. A collaborative whiteboard (Miro, Mural) holds a prepared template of the staircase. A polling tool (Mentimeter, Slido) collects the vote on the three priorities. A shared spreadsheet holds the list of first actions with their owner and date.
Sources
Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless adapted Panarchy from the work of Frances Westley. The theory of panarchy comes from the ecology of C. S. Holling.
- Henri Lipmanowicz, Keith McCandless, The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures: Simple Rules to Unleash a Culture of Innovation, 2013, ISBN 978-0-615-89337-2: the description of Panarchy with its elements, its steps and their durations, its purposes, its tips, its variations, its examples, its worksheet, the infection prevention example, the attribution to Frances Westley (Field Guide) and the strings that spread an innovation (chapter 6).
- Panarchy, Liberating Structures: the site version with its invitation, the group size, the shared chart built in front of the room, its thirteen steps in 130 minutes, the Ecocycle variation, the online run and the structures to string with it.
- C. S. Holling, "Understanding the Complexity of Economic, Ecological, and Social Systems", Ecosystems 4, 2001, pp. 390-405: the definition of panarchy, the meaning of hierarchy between levels and the revolt and remember links.

