Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Top view of two concentric circles of six people each. The people in the inner circle face outwards. Those in the outer circle face inwards. A line links each person to the partner opposite. One pair is highlighted. Its two people carry the letters A and B. A curved arrow on each circle reads "2 places". The arrow on the inner circle turns clockwise. The one on the outer circle turns anticlockwise.

Mad Tea

Mad Tea is a Liberating Structures meeting structure. Participants stand in two concentric circles and face each other in pairs. Each person completes an open sentence about a shared topic out loud while their partner listens. After thirty seconds, they switch roles. With each new sentence, everyone changes partner. Calm Tea is the online variant: everyone completes the sentences in the video call chat. Henri Lipmanowicz, Nancy White and Keith McCandless designed the structure. A session lasts 20 to 25 minutes.

Goal

According to the authors' site, Mad Tea gets people thinking differently, sharing new ideas and understanding other perspectives. It also builds fellowship and brings laughter. The site links it to the ninth Liberating Structures principle: "Engage in Seriously Playful Curiosity".

An open sentence is the start of a sentence that each person finishes in their own way: "What's working is…". In the room, each person completes up to twelve sentences and hears as many answers.

According to the book by Lipmanowicz and McCandless, Mad Tea also tempers the momentum of a group that an earlier structure has pushed to act. It builds the wider context in which the new strategies will have to work. It quickly prompts more searching reflection and new strategic ideas.

In the room, the structure leaves no document by default. All that remains is what the facilitator notes during the sharing. In that step, a few participants name the differences and similarities between the answers and what now seems possible to them. The business analyst turns these notes into a record in which each observation leads to a project action. Online, the chat keeps every answer in writing.

The business analyst uses it to open or close a workshop that brings together stakeholders from several departments. You will find the other structures of the repertoire under Liberating Structures.

Usage

When to use it

  • Opening a meeting or a workshop: the site recommends it to connect participants quickly and reach a shared purpose.
  • End of a session: each person states what they take away before leaving.
  • Transition or planning: each person states their ambitions and next steps.
  • A group in a hurry to act: after Creative Destruction, Mad Tea widens the context before the group chooses its strategies (book, Chapter 7).
  • Large group: all the pairs talk at the same time. The book reports a session at a summit of four hundred leaders.
  • Distributed team: in Calm Tea, participants complete the sentences in the video call chat.
  • Views to collect in writing: the Calm Tea chat keeps every answer for analysis.

When not to use it

  • Fewer than twelve people in the room: this is below the site's minimum; open with Impromptu Networking, which starts at four.
  • Confidential or personal subject: each person answers out loud to several partners in a room where the neighbours can hear; use an individual interview instead.

Description

The elements of the structure

The authors describe every structure through five design elements. The current page gives them for Mad Tea in the room and for Calm Tea online.

ElementMad Tea in the roomCalm Tea online
Structuring invitation"Get ready to explore our challenge at warp speed! We will be sharing our perspectives, uncovering hidden insights, and unleashing new ideas, all while having fun and inspiring our next steps."The same invitation
Space and materialsAn open space where participants stand in two concentric circles. Open sentences prepared for displayOpen sentences written in capitals to paste into the chat
Participation distributionA facilitator and the participants. At least twelve participants. Everyone completes every sentenceA facilitator, a tech host and the participants. At least six participants. Everyone completes every sentence
Group configurationPairs, then the whole group for the sharingThe whole group only
Steps and time allocationFive steps. 20 to 25 min statedFive steps. 20 to 25 min stated
The design elements of Mad Tea in the room and of Calm Tea online according to the current page of the site.

The two circles

The inner circle faces outwards and the outer circle faces inwards. Each person has a single partner opposite them.

After each sentence, everyone moves to their right and finds a new partner. The figure on the page sets the distance at two places. Its arrows turn the inner circle clockwise and the outer circle anticlockwise. The two partners face each other: the right of one is the left of the other. Each move therefore shifts the partners by four places. With an odd number of people per circle, each person meets the whole opposite circle before meeting an earlier partner again. With six or twelve people per circle, each person meets their first partner again at the fourth sentence.

Participants stand in two circles and face each other in pairs. The inner circle faces outwards and the outer circle faces inwards. After each sentence, everyone moves two places to their right: the two circles turn in opposite directions.AB2 places2 places
Participants stand in two circles and face each other in pairs. The inner circle faces outwards and the outer circle faces inwards. After each sentence, everyone moves two places to their right: the two circles turn in opposite directions.

The earlier version of the site has the facilitator remind participants of the move at the first change only. In our view, the facilitator shows the move once before the first sentence. The instruction "to their right" hides that the two circles turn in opposite directions.

With an odd total of participants, one person is left without a partner. In our view, a co-facilitator then joins the circle.

The steps in the room

  1. Introduction (1 min): the facilitator states the structuring invitation.
  2. Setup (2 min): participants form the two circles and stand facing their partner.
  3. Instructions (2 min): the facilitator displays an open sentence. In each pair, one person completes the sentence while the other listens. After thirty seconds, they switch roles. Everyone moves to their right for a new partner and a new sentence.
  4. Sentences (up to 12 min): the facilitator reads and displays the first sentence. Every thirty seconds, the facilitator signals the role switch or the change of partner. The facilitator carries on for up to twelve sentences.
  5. All-together sharing (2 to 5 min): everyone returns to the plenary. A few people say which differences and similarities they noticed between the answers and what now seems possible to them.

One sentence a minute

Each sentence takes one minute. The person who speaks has thirty seconds. The other person listens: the earlier version of the site asks the listener for full attention. According to that version, the time pressure makes everyone answer in plain statements that everyone understands.

The room gets noisy. The site asks the partners to lean in close to each other and keep their voices down. It recommends a bell or another device that everyone can hear for each transition.

  1. 0 sThe sentence appears
  2. Acompletes the sentenceBlistens
  3. 30 sSignal
  4. Bcompletes the sentenceAlistens
  5. 60 sSignal
  6. Two places to the right
  7. Next sentence (up to twelve)
One sentence lasts one minute. A completes the sentence for thirty seconds and B for the next thirty. At the second signal, everyone moves two places to their right and the next sentence appears.

Choosing and ordering the sentences

The sentences are the only material of the structure. Each one concerns the shared topic, which the facilitator displays above the sentence. The site introduces its examples with "In regard to (the topic / challenge)". It recommends a balanced mix of tones.

ToneExample from the site
Appreciative"What's working is…"
Problem-focused"The biggest challenge is…"
Hopeful"I hope it's possible to…"
Action-oriented"The next step we could take is…"
The sentence tones that the site recommends mixing and its example for each tone.

The examples on the page also cover what to keep or give up: "What must be protected is…", "What must be resisted is…", "What must be let go of is…". The book suggests "A courageous conversation we are not having is…" and "If we do nothing, the worst thing that can happen for us is…".

The site suggests varying the open part. The gap can sit in the middle of the sentence ("I hope to get … from today's session") or at its start ("… prevents teams from working well together"). Depending on the topic, the sentences can be lighter or more serious.

In our view, a useful sentence concerns a single matter that everyone knows from their own experience. "What I think of the strategy is…" invites a speech. "The risk I see in this project is…" invites an answer. The set in the book opens with an appreciative sentence: "What first inspired me in this work is…". In our view, the facilitator opens the set the same way and closes it with an action sentence. The sharing then starts from what each person intends to do.

The sharing

In our view, the business analyst notes the observations from the plenary on a flipchart. Each observation carries the number of the sentence that prompted it. In the project, each observation then leads to a requirement to investigate, a risk to log or a person to invite to the next workshop. When an observation about what seems possible records a department's offer, the business analyst enters it in the project plan under that department's responsibility.

Calm Tea online

According to the site, the physical movement of Mad Tea is hard to replicate online. The site recommends Calm Tea, where the video call chat replaces the circles. Calm Tea applies Chatterfall: each person writes their answer in the chat and sends it only at the facilitator's signal.

  1. Introduction (1 min): the facilitator states the structuring invitation.
  2. Setup and instructions (2 min): everyone mutes their microphone. The facilitator explains that each person completes the sentence in the chat and presses Enter only at the signal. Spelling and grammar mistakes are fine.
  3. Sentences (up to 12 min): the facilitator reads the sentence and pastes it into the chat. Each person types an answer. After thirty to forty seconds, the facilitator says: "Go, hit Enter." The group reads the answers for one minute. The facilitator repeats these steps for up to six sentences.
  4. Reread (2 to 3 min): everyone scrolls up and rereads the answers. They look for the differences, the similarities and what now seems possible.
  5. All-together sharing (2 to 5 min): a few participants say what they noticed out loud or in the chat.

The steps add up to 19 to 23 minutes. According to the site, participants take a round or two to stop pressing Enter by reflex. The site also suggests an anonymous variant: everyone renames themselves with the same collective pseudonym, for example "Bootsy".

  1. 20 to 25 min stated
  2. Mad Tea (in the room)19 to 22 min
  3. 1 minIntroduction
  4. 2 minSetup
  5. 2 minInstructions
  6. 12 minSentencesup to 12 sentences
  7. 2 to 5 minAll-together sharing
  8. Calm Tea (online)19 to 23 min
  9. 1 minIntroduction
  10. 2 minSetup and instructions
  11. 12 minSentencesup to 6 sentences
  12. 2 to 3 minReread
  13. 2 to 5 minAll-together sharing
Mad Tea and Calm Tea according to the site. Both forms fit within the stated 20 to 25 minutes. Calm Tea uses half as many sentences and adds a reread of the chat.

Mad Tea in a string

The 2013 book describes Mad Tea in two cases in Chapter 7, where the structure comes before Strategy Safari. In the book, Strategy Safari is a set of questions. They make the group state:

  1. what is happening around it that demands adaptation;
  2. where it honestly starts from;
  3. what seems possible given its purpose;
  4. what is at stake if it does not change;
  5. how it moves from the current state towards the future.

According to the book, the Mad Tea sentences prepare the group to answer these questions together. The questions then focus attention and produce a shared understanding of strategy and next steps.

SourceStringRole of Mad Tea
Chapter 7 of the book: strategy retreat of the leadership team and its direct reports (thirty people)Creative Destruction (TRIZ in the book), then Mad Tea and Strategy Safari, then What, So What, Now What?Temper the momentum that Creative Destruction creates and set the context for the new strategies
Chapter 7 of the book: national summit of four hundred leadersOpen Space, then Mad Tea and Strategy Safari, then What, So What, Now What?Give a strategic context to the actions that come out of Open Space
Authors' siteBefore or after Critical Uncertainties, Future~Present or Strategy KnotworkingPrepare or extend a structure that calls for imagination and curiosity
The strings in which the book and the site place Mad Tea and the role they give it.

What makes Mad Tea fail

A sentence that is too broad invites a speech that the thirty seconds cut off in the middle. A closed sentence runs dry in one word. Before the session, the facilitator completes each sentence out loud in thirty seconds.

A set made only of problems turns the session into a list of complaints. The mix of tones that the site recommends prevents this.

A signal that is too weak gets lost in the noise. Some of the pairs then keep talking and the rotation falls out of step.

Dropping the sharing step to save time leaves the answers inside the pairs. Nobody then sees the differences and similarities that the structure was meant to bring out.

Online, an answer sent before the signal appears while the others are still writing. The site makes everyone wait for the signal for this reason.

The other versions

ElementCurrent pageEarlier version (v1.2)Book (2013)
StatusA structure of the repertoireMarked Liberating Structure in DevelopmentTwo cases in Chapter 7
AuthorsHenri Lipmanowicz, Nancy White and Keith McCandlessHenri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless. Strategy questions inspired by Chris McGoff (The Primes)Not stated
Group sizeAt least twelve people in the room and six onlineNo limitNot stated. The cases bring together thirty and four hundred people
MoveTo the right. The figure specifies two placesTwo places to the rightTo the right
SignalA bell or another deviceOne ding of the bell to switch roles. Two dings to change partnerNot stated
Speaking timeThirty seconds per personThirty seconds in the steps. 20 to 50 seconds in the tipsUnder thirty seconds
Number of sentencesUp to twelve in the room and six onlineUp to fifteenFourteen in the Chapter 7 box
After the sentencesSharing on the differences, the similarities and what seems possibleA question about the experience. Then each person silently fills in a worksheet of six strategy questions (5 min)The five Strategy Safari questions
OnlineCalm Tea in the chatThe "chat to all" of a virtual conference tool. According to the site, it stays lively with hundreds of participantsNot described
Duration20 to 25 min stated. The steps add up to 19 to 22 minThe steps add up to 23 to 26 minNot stated
Mad Tea according to the current page of the site, the earlier version of the site and the 2013 book.

AI considerations

A language model suggests open sentences for a given topic. The facilitator asks it for two or three sentences per tone. The facilitator keeps those that concern a single matter that everyone knows from their own experience. A sentence such as "The main advantage of the new system is…" suggests its own answer. The facilitator discards it.

The model also translates the set for a bilingual group. A native speaker checks that each sentence stays open.

After a Calm Tea session, the model groups the chat answers by sentence and by theme to prepare the business analyst's record. The reread and the sharing stay with the participants during the session. The chat carries the participants' names: these are personal data under the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP). The collective pseudonym that the site suggests removes the names from the chat that the facilitator exports. Without it, the facilitator replaces the names before handing the text to an external AI service.

In the room, each answer goes to one person only. In our view, the facilitator does not record the pairs: a recording meant for a model would change what each person dares to say.

Examples

A regional public transport company is replacing its ticketing system. Twenty-six drivers, sales staff, IT staff and finance staff open the kick-off workshop with Mad Tea. With thirteen people per circle, each person meets a different partner for each of the eight sentences. The business analyst writes the set of sentences and then records the sharing.

No.Open sentenceTone
1"What works in our current ticketing system is…"Appreciative
2"What we must keep from the current system is…"Appreciative
3"What our customers do not understand today is…"Problem
4"The biggest risk of this replacement is…"Problem
5"I hope that by 2028 a passenger will be able to…"Hope
6"What my team can bring to the project is…"Action
7"What I need to learn before go-live is…"Action
8"The next step I can take from Monday is…"Action
Constructed case. The set of sentences that the facilitator displays under the title "Replacing our ticketing system". The "Tone" column abbreviates the tones that the site recommends.
Observation from the plenarySentenceFollow-up in the project
Difference: the sales team fears queues at the ticket machines. The IT team fears the migration of the annual passes4Two separate risks in the risk register
Similarity: everyone wants to keep on-board sales for passengers without a mobile phone2Candidate requirement to validate with management
Similarity: the drivers and the sales staff get the same questions about fare zones3Two drivers invited to the requirements workshop on buying a ticket
Possible: the IT team offers a test environment from March. The sales team offers testers6Sales staff involved in user acceptance testing (UAT)
Constructed case. The flipchart from the sharing. Each observation refers to the sentence that prompted it and leads to a project action.

The record keeps only what the plenary said: the other answers stay within the pairs.

Visualisations

One diagram shows the two circles and the move after each sentence. A second diagram breaks down the minute of one sentence. A third places the steps of Mad Tea and Calm Tea on a time axis. The design elements, the tones, the strings, the versions, the example set and its record fit in rows and columns.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowWrite and try out eight to twelve sentences, clear a space for two circles, provide a bell and a display.
ExecutionLowThe site states 20 to 25 minutes in the room and online.
DocumentationLowNone by default. A flipchart from the sharing or the Calm Tea chat to sort.

Tooling

In the room, the structure needs a space free of tables where participants stand in two circles. A screen or a flipchart displays the topic and the current sentence. A bell or a loud sound signal marks the transitions. A timer helps the facilitator keep to the thirty seconds. A second flipchart records the sharing.

Remotely, the chat of a video call (Zoom, Microsoft Teams) carries Calm Tea. The facilitator prepares the sentences in capitals in a text file. At the end of the session, the facilitator saves the chat for the record.

Sources

The current page of the site attributes Mad Tea to Henri Lipmanowicz, Nancy White and Keith McCandless. The site publishes the structure under a Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 licence.

  • Henri Lipmanowicz, Keith McCandless, The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures: Simple Rules to Unleash a Culture of Innovation, 2013, ISBN 978-0-615-89337-2: the strategy retreat and the national summit in Chapter 7, the box of open sentences and the string with the five Strategy Safari questions.
  • Mad Tea and Calm Tea, Liberating Structures: the current version with its design elements, its steps in the room and online, its tips, its variations, its sample sentences, its strings and its attribution.
  • Mad Tea (v1.2), Liberating Structures, archived site: the earlier version of the structure with its purposes, its signals, its fifteen sentences and its strategy questions worksheet.
Lift chart and cumulative gains chart
All techniques
Make-or-Buy Analysis