Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
1-2-4-All from left to right. Each participant writes alone for 1 minute. Two people exchange ideas for 2 minutes. Four people refine the ideas for 4 minutes. Each group of four shares one idea in plenary for 5 minutes.

Liberating Structures

Liberating Structures (LS) are an open-access repertoire of methods that guide a group's routine interactions in meeting rooms, classrooms and communities. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless developed them from 2001 onwards and published them in 2013 in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures. Each structure is a short script. It sets the question asked, the size of the groups, the layout of the room, the steps and their timing. The book describes 33 structures. The authors' site has added more since. 1-2-4-All has everyone write before anyone speaks. Troika Consulting has two peers advise one participant. Creative Destruction asks the group what it must stop doing.

Goal

Liberating Structures are meeting scripts that change the shape of an exchange so that every participant contributes. The authors call what sets this shape a microstructure: the make-up of the groups, the layout of the room, the format of the exchange. The facilitator changes a microstructure in a few minutes without reorganising the team.

The authors name the conventional formats: the presentation, the managed discussion, the status report, the brainstorm and the open discussion. In their view, the first three control the conversation too tightly and the last two too loosely. Either way, few participants contribute. A Liberating Structure replaces or complements one of these formats.

Each structure delivers its own result. 1-2-4-All produces the list of ideas that the plenary selects. Troika Consulting leaves each participant with the advice of two peers on their problem. Creative Destruction produces the list of practices that the group stops, with a first step for each.

A workshop sets the purpose of a session, its work product and its participants. A Liberating Structure organises 12 to 35 minutes of that session. The Fishbowl appears among the 33 original structures under the name User Experience Fishbowl.

Usage

When to use it

  • Requirements workshop where a few voices dominate: 1-2-4-All has everyone write before anyone speaks.
  • Managers present in the room: every idea passes through a pair and a group of four before the managers hear it.
  • Large group, one question: 1-2-4-All needs at least four people and sets no maximum.
  • Discussion going round in circles: 12 minutes of 1-2-4-All get the whole room writing ideas.
  • Feedback expected after a presentation: replace the Q&A with a 1-2-4-All on what the presentation changes.
  • Everyone has a problem whose context their peers know: Troika Consulting gives each person two advisers in 30 minutes without an outside expert.
  • Practices the team no longer questions: Creative Destruction has the team name what to stop, for example in a retrospective.
  • Distributed team: 1-3-All or Chatterfall in a video call, Troika Consulting with the client's camera and microphone off during the consultation.

When not to use it

  • Information that nobody in the room holds: the structures recombine what the participants know; look for it through document analysis or ask whoever holds it.
  • Subject that must stay within a small circle (an HR case about someone present, a project under embargo): the peers hear every contribution; prefer an individual interview.
  • Decision already taken: the room notices that its contribution changes nothing; announce the decision and use the structure later to plan how to implement the decision.

Description

The design elements

The authors describe every structure in terms of the same design elements. A novice facilitator follows the steps as written. An experienced facilitator adapts them to the group.

ElementWhat it setsIn 1-2-4-All
Structuring invitationThe question put to the group"Let's think about our shared challenge and generate ideas to address it."
Space and materialsThe layout of the room and what goes in itSpace for pairs and groups of four. Chairs, tables and paper optional
Participation distributionWho contributes and whenEach person writes alone, then talks in a pair and in a group of four
Group configurationThe size and make-up of the groupsAlone, in pairs, in fours, then all
Steps and time allocationThe sequence and length of each step1, 2, 4 and 5 minutes
The design elements applied to 1-2-4-All.

According to the authors, a good invitation is "precisely ambiguous". It is clear enough for everyone to know what is being asked and open enough to admit many answers. Each participant chooses their own answer. When the invitation already holds the expected answer, the room repeats that answer.

1-2-4-All

1-2-4-All moves each idea from one person alone to a pair, then to a group of four, before the plenary. Nobody speaks before writing.

  1. Alone (1 min): each person reflects in silence and notes their ideas.
  2. In pairs (2 min): the pairs generate ideas and build on what each person noted alone.
  3. In fours (4 min): two pairs join to share and develop their ideas. The group notes what the ideas have in common and where they differ.
  4. All (5 min): each group of four shares one idea with the whole room. No group repeats an idea already shared.

According to the book, 1-2-4-All takes 12 minutes.

Alone1 min
write
In pairs2 min
exchange
In fours4 min
refine
All5 min
share
Each participant writes alone, then talks in a pair and in a group of four. Each group of four then shares one idea in plenary. The durations come from the book.

The facilitator keeps time to the minute and protects the minute of silence. When the room talks during the individual step, the fastest speakers take the floor again. The facilitator steps into the groups' conversations as little as possible. In the plenary, a group of four that reads out its whole list turns the session into a status report. When every group of four must be heard, a flash round gives each group one sentence. On a sheet, the facilitator records the ideas that the plenary selects.

The authors suggest a second round to dig deeper. For an online or very large group, 1-3-All replaces the pair and the group of four with a trio. The authors warn that one person can then dominate the trio. Online, Chatterfall has each person type an idea in the chat. Nobody sends their message until the facilitator gives the signal. Then everyone reads.

You'll find more detail on this structure in the 1-2-4-All fiche.

Troika Consulting

Troika Consulting has two peers advise each participant. Participants work in threes on chairs without a table. In each round, one participant is the client and the other two are consultants.

  1. Introduction (1 min): each person reflects on their problem and the help they need.
  2. Briefing (1 to 2 min): the client presents their problem and the help they need.
  3. Questions (1 to 2 min): the consultants ask clarifying questions.
  4. Consultation (4 to 5 min): the client turns their back on the consultants. The consultants discuss the problem with each other and offer ideas and advice.
  5. Takeaways (1 to 2 min): the client turns back round and says what helped most.
  6. Rounds 2 and 3: steps 2 to 5 run again with a new client so that each person is client once.

According to the book, Troika Consulting takes 30 minutes.

During the consultation, the consultants talk about the problem without watching for the client's reaction. The client listens and has no chance to correct or explain. The authors advise showing the group how the client turns their back before the first round and telling the room that turning one's back is not rude. They also advise forming diverse trios so that each client hears other perspectives on their problem. Online, the client switches off camera and microphone during the consultation. If a round does not help the client, the trio runs it again with another problem.

Briefing and questions
Consultation
During the consultation, the client turns their back. The consultants discuss the problem with each other and the client listens.

Speed Troika shortens each step. Q-storming restricts the consultants to questions.

Creative Destruction

Creative Destruction has the group describe the worst possible result of its work. The group then identifies what it already does to reach that result and decides what it stops doing. Participants work in groups of four to seven. Each person has paper and each group has a flipchart or a whiteboard.

The authors' site also calls this structure TRIZ. It uses neither the inventive principles nor the contradiction matrix of Genrich Altshuller's TRIZ.

  1. Introduction (5 min): the facilitator reads the invitation: "Let's make space for innovation by identifying the worst possible result of our work." The group refines this worst result. For IT professionals, the page suggests: "How can we make sure we build an IT system that no one will want to use?"
  2. List (10 min): each group runs a 1-2-4-All. In it, each person lists everything they could do to get this worst result. The group then combines the ideas into one list.
  3. Reckoning (10 min): the group runs a 1-2-4-All and identifies everything it already does that resembles an item on its list, even remotely.
  4. Destruction (10 min): the group runs a 1-2-4-All, decides what it stops doing and writes the first steps.

According to the book, Creative Destruction takes 35 minutes. The book gives 10 minutes to each of the last three steps without dividing them among the steps of 1-2-4-All. The facilitator shortens those steps to fit.

The group names behaviours to stop. A list of projects to launch leads back to the usual brainstorm. The facilitator starts from a very unwanted result and has the group confirm it quickly. In a large group the lists converge fast: the facilitator has each list reviewed with a critical eye. According to the authors, the group may slip back into its old habits after the session. The first step written for each practice gives the follow-up a checkpoint.

Combining structures

The authors distinguish two ways of combining structures. In nesting, one structure runs inside a step of another. A string is a sequence of structures in which each one feeds the next. Creative Destruction nests 1-2-4-All in its three 10-minute steps. Its page suggests stringing Troika Consulting next. Each participant brings the first step they committed to and receives the advice of two peers.

Introduction5 min
List10 min
nested: 1-2-4-AllAloneIn pairsIn foursAll
Reckoning10 min
nested: 1-2-4-AllAloneIn pairsIn foursAll
Destruction10 min
nested: 1-2-4-AllAloneIn pairsIn foursAll
Troika Consulting30 min
Creative Destruction runs each of its three 10-minute steps as a 1-2-4-All. Its page then suggests Troika Consulting, where each person submits their first step to two peers.

The facilitator prepares a string like a workshop session. They write the invitation for each structure, plan the move from one group configuration to the next and add up the durations from the book. For the two structures they total 65 minutes without counting the move from groups of four to seven into trios.

What makes a structure fail

Loose timekeeping makes a structure fail. Each step that overruns takes time from the next. The plenary comes last and loses that time.

AI considerations

To prepare the session, a language model proposes several wordings of the invitation. The facilitator keeps the one that names the problem without suggesting an answer. The model also drafts the timing of a string and the instructions to display at each step. Online, it groups the contributions of a Chatterfall or the plenary notes by theme. The facilitator reviews this grouping with the room.

The model replaces no step in which a participant thinks or speaks. An idea generated before the silent minute of 1-2-4-All steers all the others: the room comments on the model's proposal instead of writing its own. In Troika Consulting, the consultants know the client's organisation. A model does not. In the Reckoning step of Creative Destruction, only the group knows what it already does.

The problems raised in a Troika often concern people, conflicts or unannounced projects. A session transcript then contains personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP). The facilitator announces any recording. They anonymise the transcript before handing it to an AI service hosted by a third party.

Examples

Each time the group widens, 1-2-4-All makes the ideas more precise. The example is constructed: a team of twelve at an OASI compensation office prepares its salary declaration portal for go-live.

StepDurationWhoWhat is written
Alone1 minAnna"migration" · "acceptance test" · "date"
In pairs2 minAnna and Luc"Migrate the inactive accounts?" · "Who signs off the acceptance test?" · "Go-live date"
In fours4 minAnna, Luc, Sara and Marc"Migrate or archive the 4'000 inactive accounts" · "Acceptance test sign-off: business unit or IT" · "Date: withdrawn because it follows from the two decisions"
All5 minAll twelveSelected: "Migrate or archive the inactive accounts" · "Acceptance test sign-off" · "Migration data freeze before or after employer training" (another group of four)
Record of a 1-2-4-All on the invitation "Which decisions block the portal's go-live?". Constructed example. Each row gives what is written at one step.

The plenary does not read out the lists. It selects the decisions that the whole room needs to know.

Visualisations

The 1-2-4-All circles show the group widening and the length of each step. The trio layout shows the client with their back turned during the Troika Consulting consultation. The Creative Destruction diagram nests 1-2-4-All in the three 10-minute steps and then strings Troika Consulting. The design elements and the example record are tables.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowThe facilitator writes the invitation. The session needs a room where pairs, trios or groups can form. Creative Destruction needs a flipchart per group.
ExecutionLow to medium12 minutes for 1-2-4-All, 30 for Troika Consulting and 35 for Creative Destruction according to the book.
DocumentationLowA photo of the plenary sheet. Creative Destruction adds the list of practices to stop and their first steps.

Tooling

Chairs, paper and a timer that everyone can see are enough for 1-2-4-All and Troika Consulting. Creative Destruction needs a flipchart or a whiteboard per group.

Remotely, a video call with breakout rooms (Zoom, Microsoft Teams) forms the pairs, trios and groups of four. The video call's chat carries Chatterfall. A collaborative whiteboard (Miro, Mural) holds the Creative Destruction lists and the plenary notes.

The authors' site publishes each structure on a page in the same format: invitation, design elements, timed steps, tips and variations. The facilitator prints the page or displays it during the session.

Sources

The method rests on the writings of Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless. In their view, the only condition for using LS is the willingness to try, fail, learn and share. The site publishes the structures under a Creative Commons BY-SA 4.0 licence.

Lewin's Change Model
All techniques
Lift chart and cumulative gains chart