Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Constructed case. A grid crosses two axes. The horizontal axis carries the pace of legislative revisions, from "Rare revisions" on the left to "Frequent revisions" on the right. The vertical axis carries the available specialists, from "Scarce specialists" at the bottom to "Plentiful specialists" at the top. Top left is "Smooth sailing": the law changes little and staff are easy to find. The office has time to replace its system. Top right is "Always under construction": a revision comes into force every year. The office recruits easily and adapts its system continuously. Bottom right is "Storm at the counter": revisions follow one another at short notice. Posts stay vacant for six months and the adaptations fall behind. Bottom left is "Dead calm": the law changes little. The specialists retire and take their knowledge of the system with them.

Critical Uncertainties

Critical Uncertainties is a meeting structure in which a group picks the two most critical and most uncertain factors in its environment. Crossing them forms a grid of four scenarios. Small groups write one scenario per quadrant and look for strategies to succeed in it. The whole group then sorts the strategies. A robust strategy succeeds in several scenarios. A hedging strategy succeeds in only one but protects against a plausible calamity. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless describe the structure in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures (2013). The book gives it 100 minutes. The authors' site states about 90.

Goal

Critical Uncertainties is a meeting structure from the Liberating Structures. A group uses it to build four scenarios from the two most critical and most uncertain factors in its environment.

According to the book, the structure tests the viability of current strategies by exposing their assumptions and uncertainties. It separates robust priorities from hedging priorities. It widens the range of strategic options. The authors also credit it with effects on the group: everyone adapts faster to disruption and the organisation faces an unknowable future with more confidence.

The structure produces a list of strategies classed as robust or hedging, then the first steps that the group decides on. According to the book, it prepares the group for strategy making.

The business analyst uses it ahead of a strategy or a programme whose environment can change: a legislative revision, a tight labour market, a technology that may take hold or disappear. The robust strategies then feed the solution options and the risk analysis. You will find the full repertoire under Liberating Structures.

Usage

When to use it

  • Current strategy in a shifting environment: test the current strategy against four plausible futures.
  • Ten-year strategic vision: the book cites executives and operational managers who prepare it with the structure.
  • Product or service to launch: the book and the site use it to choose the features to include.
  • Roll-out across several countries or sites: the book cites IT managers who use it to prepare the implementation.
  • Group caught off guard by a change in funding or public opinion: the book cites NGO leadership teams.
  • Missing or unreliable forecasts: the group chooses the axes from its history and its experience on the ground.
  • Distributed team: according to the site, the structure works online without major adaptation.

When not to use it

  • Schedule delay question: what-if scenario analysis recalculates the end date and the critical path.
  • Predictable future and options already defined: compare them on weighted criteria with a decision matrix.

Description

The elements of the structure

The authors describe each structure by five design elements. The site revises the version in the 2013 book. It changes the invitation, the group sizes and the online format.

ElementBook (2013)Authors' site
Structuring invitationIdentify and study the most critical and most uncertain "realities" of the operating environment or market. Then formulate strategies to succeed in those situations"Let's develop four plausible future scenarios and identify strategies that would help us succeed in each. Then we will review options to make our current strategies more adaptable. The future is uncertain, but we can prepare for it."
Space and materialsFour groups of chairs around tables. Paper, sticky notes and flip charts for each groupAn open wall to draw the grid. Groups of four chairs around small tables. Sticky notes and large paper for each group
Distribution of participationEveryone who plans and executes the strategy. Everyone has an equal opportunity to contributeThe same people, a facilitator and a group of at least eight people
Group configurationFour small groups that take one quadrant each. Two groups if the headcount is too smallIdeally four groups of four or five. Fewer than twelve people: two groups that each cover two to four quadrants. More than twenty: several groups per quadrant and extra time for sharing
Duration100 min stated. The steps add up to 93 minAbout 90 min stated. The steps add up to 92 min
OnlineNot describedBreakout rooms, a grid template prepared in a shared space, polls or digital dot voting
The design elements of Critical Uncertainties in the 2013 book and on the authors' site.

Choosing the two axes

According to the book, each axis carries one of the "two most critical and most uncertain" factors. A critical factor threatens the group's ability to succeed. An uncertain factor is impossible to predict or control.

A factor that is critical but predictable enters every scenario as a given. A factor that is uncertain but minor leaves the strategy unchanged. The group keeps both off the grid.

FactorCriticalUncertainPlace in the grid
Pace of legislative revisions (OASI, DI, income compensation and family allowances)Yes: each revision changes the system's calculationsYesHorizontal axis
IT and social insurance specialists available on the labour marketYes: every adaptation of the system depends on themYesVertical axis
Number of pensioners in 2035YesNo: the pensioners of 2035 are already bornA given in all four scenarios
Price of office software licencesNo: a price rise has little effect on the budgetYesDropped
Constructed case. A cantonal compensation office chooses the axes of its grid for 2035. Only the factors that are both critical and uncertain become axes.

Each axis runs from a "more of" end to a "less of" end. In the book's example, the X axis runs from a large number of new products to none. The Y axis runs from strong patent protection to none.

The steps

The book and the site count the same twelve steps. The timings differ only at the introduction. The book times the sharing of scenarios and of strategies at 2 minutes per group. That makes 8 minutes for four groups.

  1. Introduction (2 min in the book, 1 min on the site): the facilitator presents the invitation and the sequence of steps.
  2. List the uncertainties (5 min): participants answer the book's question "In our operating environment, what factors are impossible to predict or control their direction?"
  3. Pick out the critical factors (10 min): the group looks for the factors that threaten its ability to succeed. According to the site, participants do this work in pairs over a five-to-ten-year horizon.
  4. Choose the two axes (5 min): in plenary, the group chooses the two most critical and most uncertain factors. It draws on its history and its experience on the ground. In a large group, the site has people vote with dots or a poll.
  5. Draw the grid (5 min): the group draws the two axes on a large sheet of paper and names their ends. Crossing them forms four quadrants.
  6. Write the scenarios (10 min): each small group takes one quadrant. It gives the quadrant a creative name and writes a short scenario. The site limits the scenario to two sentences.
  7. Share the scenarios (8 min): in plenary, each group presents the name and the scenario of its quadrant.
  8. Look for strategies (10 min): each group looks for three strategies to succeed in its scenario.
  9. Share the strategies (8 min): each group briefly presents its strategies. As an option, the site has everyone write in the chat, then gives the floor to a few people.
  10. Sort the strategies (10 min): the whole group separates the robust strategies from the hedging strategies.
  11. Debrief (10 min): the small groups debrief with What, So What, Now What?. The site forms new groups of three to six people. They compare the current strategy with the strategies found.
  12. Decide on first steps (10 min): according to the book, the groups share their debriefs and the whole group decides on the first steps. According to the site, a few participants share the first steps that everyone needs to hear.
  1. 1 Introduction · 1 min11 minPlenary
  2. 2 Uncertainties25 minNot specified
  3. 3 Critical factors310 minIn pairs
  4. 4 Two axes45 minPlenary
  5. 5 Grid55 minPlenary
  6. 6 Scenarios610 minQuadrant groups
  7. 7 Sharing scenarios78 minPlenary
  8. 8 Strategies810 minQuadrant groups
  9. 9 Sharing strategies98 minPlenary
  10. 10 Sort1010 minPlenary
  11. 11 Debrief1110 minNew groups of three to six
  12. 12 First steps1210 minPlenary
  1. 1Introduction1 minPlenary
  2. 2Uncertainties5 minNot specified
  3. 3Critical factors10 minIn pairs
  4. 4Two axes5 minPlenary
  5. 5Grid5 minPlenary
  6. 6Scenarios10 minQuadrant groups
  7. 7Sharing scenarios8 minPlenary
  8. 8Strategies10 minQuadrant groups
  9. 9Sharing strategies8 minPlenary
  10. 10Sort10 minPlenary
  11. 11Debrief10 minNew groups of three to six
  12. 12First steps10 minPlenary
  • Plenary
  • In pairs
  • Quadrant groups
  • New groups of three to six
  • Not specified
The steps on the authors' site: twelve steps in 92 minutes. The small groups each work on one quadrant. The whole group pools the scenarios, then the strategies. It then sorts the strategies.

Sorting the strategies

A robust strategy can succeed in several quadrants. A hedging strategy succeeds in only one scenario. According to the book, it protects the group from a plausible calamity. According to the site, it prepares the group for big disruptions and surprises.

According to the book, the other strategies succeed in only one scenario.

For the sort, the facilitator puts up a table with one column per quadrant. For each strategy, the group marks the quadrants where it succeeds. According to the book, sticky notes help to combine ideas. The group merges similar strategies before marking them.

Running the session

To list the uncertainties, the facilitator has the group recall forecasts that proved wrong and events that caught it off guard. The facilitator questions wishful thinking. The site also has the facilitator correct factual errors about the past.

The facilitator uses 1-2-4-All in very short cycles at each step. Each person thinks alone, then in pairs, then in fours before the whole group pools the ideas.

The group names the quadrants with humour. Song and book titles make good names. The book also suggests writing each scenario as a newspaper article. The site advises a break halfway through the session to prevent cognitive overload.

Variations

The site suggests preparing the two uncertainties in advance and skipping the first three steps. The session saves fifteen to twenty minutes. In our view, a facilitator who prepares the axes has the group validate them at the start of the session. Otherwise the choice of axes remains one person's.

The book suggests other variations. For each scenario, small groups act out a typical interaction with a customer or a product of the future. The scene shows the strategies at work. The short session can also open a full scenario-planning process.

Online, the site has the grid template prepared in a shared space because a remote group loses too much time drawing it during the session.

After the session

The business analyst carries each category from the sort into a deliverable. The robust strategies go into the solution options and the business case. A hedging strategy goes into the risk register as a planned response with its trigger. The single-scenario strategies go on a watch list with the signal that would announce their scenario. In the compensation office example, the framework contract for three developers goes into the register with the trigger "revision passed with less than a year before it comes into force".

What makes Critical Uncertainties fail

An axis that is critical but predictable skews the grid. Two of its quadrants describe a future that the group knows to be unlikely. The group checks each axis with one question: "Could we bet on one of the ends?" If so, the factor leaves the grid.

A group that writes four comfortable scenarios tests nothing. The facilitator assigns the most uncomfortable quadrant instead of letting the groups choose. The scenario for that quadrant describes in concrete terms what happens to the organisation.

A vague strategy succeeds everywhere without committing to anything. "Stay agile" ticks all four quadrants. A strategy names an action that the organisation can launch. The facilitator sends back to the group any strategy that names none.

The session produces sorted strategies and first steps. The facilitator says so from the invitation onwards so that nobody expects a plan.

Critical Uncertainties in a string

The authors combine several Liberating Structures into a string. Chapter 6 of the book follows Critical Uncertainties with Wise Crowds and 15% Solutions. Critical Uncertainties produces strategies tested against an unpredictable future. The two structures that follow give each person advice from several disciplines on their share of the implementation.

Chapter 7 describes a leadership retreat. On the second morning, Open Space moves each selected strategy forward. Critical Uncertainties then assesses how useful each strategy is in four future environments. The gaps it brings to light feed the next retreat.

The book also pairs the structure with Conversation Café, Purpose-To-Practice, What I Need From You, Open Space, Wicked Questions and Min Specs.

Origin

The book says the structure was inspired by the consultant Jay Ogilvy. The site points to the scenario-planning work of the Global Business Network.

Critical Uncertainties reduces the 2×2 grid to a group exercise of 90 to 100 minutes.

AI considerations

The site suggests using generative AI to create scenarios and strategies from two uncertainties set in advance. A language model can write a first draft of the scenario for each quadrant. The group corrects it and adds what it knows from field experience.

The model does not choose the axes. It knows the general uncertainties of a sector. The book has the group choose the axes from its own history and experience, which the model does not know.

During the sort, the model can suggest the quadrants where each strategy would succeed. It also flags the vague strategies that tick every box. The group decides because the model lacks facts such as whether the office can recruit within six months.

The strategies and scenarios often describe confidential projects. The facilitator gives them only to an AI service that the organisation has approved for this type of document.

Examples

The deliverable is the list of sorted strategies. Each row shows in which scenarios the strategy succeeds.

Plentiful specialists
Available specialists
Scarce specialists
Smooth sailing
Rare revisions · Plentiful specialists
The law changes little and staff are easy to find. The office has time to replace its system.
Always under construction
Frequent revisions · Plentiful specialists
A revision comes into force every year. The office recruits easily and adapts its system continuously.
Storm at the counter
Frequent revisions · Scarce specialists
Revisions follow one another at short notice. Posts stay vacant for six months and the adaptations fall behind.
Dead calm
Rare revisions · Scarce specialists
The law changes little. The specialists retire and take their knowledge of the system with them.
Rare revisions
Pace of legislative revisions
Frequent revisions
Constructed case
Constructed case. A cantonal compensation office crosses the pace of legislative revisions with the availability of specialists for 2035. Each quadrant carries a name and a two-sentence scenario.
StrategyAlways under constructionStorm at the counterDead calmSmooth sailingClassification
Move the calculation rules out of the code into tables that the case officers configureYesYesYesNo: the new system replaces the old oneRobust
Document each calculation rule with the article of law it applies and train a deputy for each areaYesYesYesYesRobust
Share the work of adapting systems to legislative revisions with other cantonal compensation officesYesYesNoNoRobust
Sign a framework contract with a supplier that provides three developers within four weeksNoYesNoNoHedging: protects against an urgent revision with nobody to implement it
Current strategy: replace the core system in a single four-year projectNoNoNoYesSingle scenario
Constructed case. The cantonal compensation office sorts four of the strategies that its groups found and its current strategy. Each quadrant column shows whether the strategy succeeds there.

The office's current strategy succeeds only in the most comfortable quadrant. At the debrief, the group compares it with the robust strategies. It decides on a first step: inventory the calculation rules coded in the system.

Visualisations

One diagram places the four scenarios of the example on the grid of their two axes. A second diagram shows the site's twelve steps on a time axis and the group configuration at each step. The comparison of versions, the choice of axes and the sorting of strategies are tables.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowWrite the invitation, set out four tables and prepare the paper and the blank grid. More if the facilitator prepares the two axes in advance.
ExecutionMedium90 to 100 minutes with everyone who plans and executes the strategy. A group of at least eight people according to the site.
DocumentationLowPhotograph the grid and enter the sorted strategies and the first steps in a table.

Tooling

In the room, each group has sticky notes, markers and a flip chart or a large sheet of paper. The grid goes on an open wall or on a whiteboard. The facilitator paces the steps with a visible timer. In a large group, the participants vote on the axes with dot stickers.

Remotely, the facilitator uses a video conference with breakout rooms (Zoom, Microsoft Teams). A collaborative whiteboard (Miro, Mural) holds the prepared grid template. A built-in poll replaces the dot stickers. The facilitator keeps the sort table in a shared spreadsheet.

Sources

Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless designed Critical Uncertainties. The structure draws on scenario planning. The book is published under a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 3.0 licence. The site publishes the structures under a CC BY-SA 4.0 licence.

  • Henri Lipmanowicz, Keith McCandless, The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures: Simple Rules to Unleash a Culture of Innovation, 2013, ISBN 978-0-615-89337-2: the description of Critical Uncertainties with its elements, steps, purposes, tips, variations and examples, its attribution to Jay Ogilvy (Field Guide), the string with Wise Crowds and 15% Solutions (chapter 6) and the leadership retreat (chapter 7).
  • Critical Uncertainties, Liberating Structures: the site's version with its invitation, the group sizes, the minimum of eight people, the steps and their timings, online facilitation, the variations, the use of generative AI and the reference to the Global Business Network.
  • Rafael Ramirez, Angela Wilkinson, "Rethinking the 2x2 scenario method: Grid or frames?", Technological Forecasting and Social Change 86, 2014, pp. 254-264: the divergent interpretations of the 2×2 grid in scenario planning.
Critical path method
All techniques
CRUD Matrix