Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
Illustrative case of a cantonal IT department. On the vertical axis, agreement decreases from bottom to top. On the horizontal axis, certainty decreases from left to right. Four zones nest outward from the bottom left corner: Simple, Complicated, Complex and Chaotic. Challenges 1 and 4 are in the Simple zone: the office software licences and the counter opening hours page. Challenge 2 is in the Complicated zone: the migration of the residents' register. Challenge 3 is in the Complex zone: the municipalities' online counter. An arrow links challenge 3 to the Complicated zone, where its current method belongs: a rollout plan with a single date. Another arrow links challenge 4 to the Complex zone, where its current method belongs: a working group of six departments.

Agreement-Certainty Matrix

Agreement-Certainty Matrix is a Liberating Structures meeting structure. A group uses two questions to sort its challenges. In the sources, a "challenge" is any problem, project or activity that occupies the group. The first question asks how far the participants agree on the challenge and on how to address it. The second asks how predictable the results of the solutions under consideration are. The two answers place each challenge in one of four types: simple, complicated, complex or chaotic. The group then compares the type of each challenge with the method it uses to address it and records the mismatches. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless describe the structure in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures (2013) and on their site. They adapted it from the work of Ralph Stacey and Brenda Zimmerman. The book gives it 45 minutes. The site gives about 50.

Goal

Agreement-Certainty Matrix is a session in which a group checks that each of its challenges receives the method that suits its type. The book starts from a frequent mistake: a group addresses a problem with a method unsuited to its nature. These mismatches often cause chronic problems.

The structure reduces wasted effort by matching methods to challenges. It finds where local experiments can help solve larger problems. It makes the range and nature of the organisation's challenges visible to everyone. It reduces the frustration of people who make no progress on their important challenges, because it names the mismatches. It shares perspectives across functions and hierarchical levels. The site links the structure to the tenth Liberating Structures principle: Never Start Without Clear Purpose(s).

The deliverable is the completed matrix with the list of mismatches. From it the group draws up a table that pairs each mismatch with its action steps.

Usage

When to use it

  • Start of an improvement project: choose a mix of change methods suited to the project's challenges.
  • Planning group stuck in analysis: the sorting shows which challenges call for action rather than more analysis.
  • Departmental project portfolio: sort the projects by type and check the method of each.
  • Chronic problems: check whether the method in use suits the type of the problem.
  • Managers trained in linear cause-and-effect analysis: show them what sets a complex challenge apart.
  • Challenges shared across departments and hierarchical levels: each function sees where the others place the same challenges.
  • Top 10 from 25/10 Crowd Sourcing: place the ten selected ideas on the matrix.
  • Distributed team: the structure works online with no major adjustment.

When not to use it

  • Ranking challenges by importance: the matrix gives the type of a challenge, not its rank. See prioritisation.
  • Establishing the cause of a problem: the matrix sorts the problem without looking for its cause. See root cause analysis.
  • Settling a disagreement between stakeholders: the matrix locates the disagreement without resolving it. See negotiation.

Description

The two questions

The book asks: "What is the degree of agreement among the participants regarding the challenge and the best way to address it? What is the degree of certainty and predictability about what results will be generated from the solutions proposed for addressing the challenge?" The site asks a small group about its degree of agreement on the complexity of the challenge. It also asks about the group's degree of certainty about the challenge or about the results it will generate.

The vertical axis shows agreement and starts at the bottom. There the participants cooperate and share their aims. At the top, their aims are multiple and divergent. The horizontal axis shows certainty and starts at the left. There the problem and the solution are clear. To the right, they become clear only as the group investigates them. These poles come from the site's visuals.

According to Zimmerman, a question is close to certainty when its cause-and-effect links can be established. That is usually the case when the organisation has already settled a very similar question. Far from certainty, the situation is new to the decision makers. Past experience no longer predicts the results.

Zimmerman has groups discuss the factors that bring a question closer to the zone of complexity: the number of people or institutions involved, the delay between the cause and its possible effects, the turbulence or unpredictability of the field. The group places each challenge relative to the others.

The four types of challenges

TypeWhat defines it (book)Suitable method (site)
SimplePractices that are easy to reproduce solve the problem reliably.Apply best practices.
ComplicatedExperts devise a sophisticated solution that yields the desired result predictably.Call on expert facilitation and analysis.
ComplexSeveral ways of proceeding are valid. The detailed results remain unpredictable.Launch distributed trials and experiments.
ChaoticThe context is too turbulent to discern a path.Limit the harm and wait for calm to return.
The four types of challenges with their definition according to the book and the method that the site's matrix template associates with each.

Simple is like following a recipe. Complicated is like sending a rocket to the moon. Complex is like raising a child. Chaotic is like the children's game Pin the Tail on the Donkey.

Far from agreement: multiple and divergent aims

Agreement

Close to agreement: shared aims

SimpleFollowinga recipeComplicatedSending a rocketto the moonComplexRaisinga childChaoticPinning the tailon the donkey

Close to certainty: problem and solution are clear

Certainty

Far from certainty: problem and solution become clear only as the group investigates them

Far from agreement: multiple and divergent aims
Close to agreement: shared aims
Close to certainty: problem and solution are clear
Far from certainty: problem and solution become clear only as the group investigates them
Simple Following a recipe
Complicated Sending a rocket to the moon
Complex Raising a child
Chaotic Pinning the tail on the donkey
The two answers locate a challenge on the matrix. Agreement decreases upward. Certainty decreases to the right. The zone boundaries overlap.

The zones nest outward from the origin. Simple occupies the corner where agreement and certainty are highest. Chaotic occupies the opposite corner. Complicated and complex stretch between the two. The book's figure draws several overlapping dotted boundaries.

The elements of the structure

Structuring invitation. The facilitator invites the participants to sort their current challenges as simple, complicated, complex or chaotic. Each person places each challenge according to their answers to the two questions. The participants then examine the methods they use or are considering for each challenge and identify the mismatches. The site invites the group to match its methods to its challenges in order to choose more effective solutions.

Space and materials. The participants sit in groups of 4 to 6. Small round tables are optional. A large paper matrix covers a long open wall. Each participant receives a page with a blank matrix, sticky notes and a marker. The site also displays two visuals: the four types of challenges and the matrix template with the suitable methods.

How participation is distributed. The facilitator invites every member of the team or unit concerned. The leaders are only part of that group. Everyone has the same opportunity to contribute. The site provides for a host, plus a tech host online.

How groups are configured. Each person starts alone. Small groups of 4 to 6 compare and place the challenges. The whole group pools the results.

The steps according to the site

  1. Introduction (3 min). The facilitator reads the invitation. They present the four types of challenges and display their descriptions.

  2. Individual list (2 min). Each person notes the challenges they face.

  3. Shared list (3 min). The groups of 4 to 6 compare their lists and draw up a list of common challenges.

  4. Template introduction (3 min). The facilitator hands out the matrix template. For each type, they give an example from the participants' context.

  5. First placement (5 min). Each group chooses a challenge and places it according to its answers to the two questions.

  6. Further placements (5 min). The groups place the other challenges in the same way.

  7. Current methods (3 min). Each group chooses an important challenge and lists the methods that address it today.

  8. Fit (15 min). Each group compares the type of the challenge with the current methods. It flags the mismatches with the help of the examples and the guidance in the matrix template.

  9. Sharing (10 min). In plenary, each group posts its challenges and its mismatches on a large matrix. The whole group reflects on the patterns it observes.

The steps total 49 minutes. The site gives about 50.

The book's version

  1. Individual list (5 min). Each person lists the challenges that take up their time.

  2. Individual matrix (5 min). Each person places their challenges on their own matrix.

  3. Pairs (5 min). The participants discuss their placements in pairs.

  4. Small groups (10 min). Groups of 4 to 6 look for points of agreement, differences and mismatches.

  5. Wall (5 min). Everyone posts their challenges on the large wall matrix.

  6. Patterns (5 min). In small groups, the participants step back: "What pattern do we see? Do any mismatches stand out that we should address?"

  7. Plenary (10 min). The whole group shares its reflections and decides the next steps.

Placing the challengesComparison with the current methods

Site (49 min)

1Introduction 3 minPlenary
2Individual list 2 minAlone
3Shared list 3 minGroups of 4 to 6
4Template introduction 3 minPlenary
5First placement 5 minGroups of 4 to 6Placing the challenges
6Further placements 5 minGroups of 4 to 6Placing the challenges
7Current methods 3 minGroups of 4 to 6Comparison with the current methods
8Fit 15 minGroups of 4 to 6Comparison with the current methods
9Sharing 10 minPlenary

Book (45 min)

1Individual list 5 minAlone
2Individual matrix 5 minAlonePlacing the challenges
3Pairs 5 minPairs
4Small groups 10 minGroups of 4 to 6Comparison with the current methods
5Wall 5 minPlenary
6Patterns 5 minGroups of 4 to 6Comparison with the current methods
7Plenary 10 minPlenary
The two versions of the sequence. The site has the challenges placed in groups. The book has each person place them alone. The marked steps compare the type of each challenge with the current methods.

In the book, each person places their challenges alone before any discussion. The differences between the individual matrices then feed the pairs and the small groups. The site first has the groups merge their lists. The groups then place the challenges together. The site devotes two steps to the current methods and their fit. The book asks this question in the invitation and at the patterns step.

Judging the fit

The group compares the current method with the one that the type of the challenge calls for. A mismatch exists when the method belongs to another type. A detailed plan with fixed milestones treats a challenge as complicated. Applied to a complex challenge, it promises a predictability that the challenge does not offer. A working group that studies a simple question uses up meetings on a problem that a procedure would settle.

The mismatch runs both ways. Zimmerman observed it between the board and the staff of a non-profit organisation. The board complicated simple questions. The staff oversimplified. After the sorting, the participants saw that they had applied simple methods to complex problems and vice versa.

The book suggests asking: "Where are there mismatches in your approach; what countermeasures make sense?"

Running the session

The facilitator first specifies which challenges and activities the exercise covers.

They do not judge the placements. A participant who places a challenge in the chaotic zone says what they perceive. A comment from the facilitator would push them toward the expected answer.

A challenge that falls into several zones calls for a question. The book suggests: "Does this challenge have multiple dynamics at play? How is it simultaneously simple and complex?"

Groups sometimes spend too long defining the challenge. The site then asks the facilitator to bring them back to how to address it.

Zimmerman advises starting with past challenges, then moving on to current or future ones. She also has the group discuss which methods suit each zone and why.

What makes Agreement-Certainty Matrix fail

Sorting without comparison produces nothing. The group places its challenges and the session stops there. The facilitator gives the comparison the time that the site allots to it: 18 of the 49 minutes.

The four-box grid forces each challenge into one box. The zone boundaries overlap. The group puts the book's question to a challenge that straddles two zones. It names the part of the challenge that behaves as simple and the part that behaves as complex. It writes each part on its own note and gives it its own method. This split comes from practice.

The agreement of those present looks higher than it is. If a department that the challenge affects is absent, its disagreement does not enter the placement. The book invites the whole unit concerned. For a challenge that touches other departments, the facilitator also invites their representatives. This remedy comes from practice.

A quick consensus deserves a second question. At a retreat facilitated by Zimmerman, every group classified each challenge in the same or nearly the same way. The participants then asked themselves whether a question judged simple really was simple. They also asked whether they would be better off leaving it in the zone of complexity for a while.

A frozen placement goes out of date. The participants at this retreat noted that questions change zones. External conditions and the participants' point of view move them. The group redoes the matrix when the context changes.

The hierarchy in the room pushes challenges toward simple. A participant who places their manager's project in the complex zone tells the manager in front of the others that the plan will not hold. The book's individual work limits this effect: each person places their challenges before hearing the others. The site's version leaves the participants more exposed to this trap: there the groups place the challenges together after merging the lists. In this version, the facilitator forms groups with no direct reporting line between their members. They can also borrow the book's step in which each person places their challenges alone and add it to the site's version. This trap and its remedy come from practice.

Variations

The site suggests having the participants hold up a sign reading "Chaotic", "Complex", "Complicated" or "Simple" to show their degree of agreement. The book suggests applying the structure to a single problem. Right after the structure, the site suggests the LS Selection Matchmaker to find ways of addressing complex challenges.

The book reports a version in physical space. In the United States, Tim Jaasko-Fisher facilitated a one-hour workshop with 70 child welfare stakeholders: judges, lawyers, court clerks and social workers. Each participant judged the challenge they had named at the start of the workshop. They then took up a position in the room: at the front for simple, at the back for chaotic. Most stood in the complicated and complex zones. The room reduces the matrix to a single line. Each person's position shows the type of their challenge. It no longer shows which of the two questions decided that type. This reading is a practitioner's judgement. During the 1-2-4-All that followed, the group found that the social interaction needed increased from simple to chaotic. Authority and expertise settled most simple problems. Complex problems required getting people to work together: consensus and dialogue.

Agreement-Certainty Matrix in strings

The book strings the matrix with structures that develop a strategy: Critical Uncertainties, Purpose-To-Practice, Ecocycle, Panarchy, Integrated~Autonomy and Discovery & Action Dialogue. The site suggests addressing the mismatches with Discovery & Action Dialogue, Panarchy or Strategy Knotworking to produce more local prototypes.

Other structures in the book refer back to the matrix. Generative Relationships STAR suggests it when a group scores low on the Tuning axis. 25/10 Crowd Sourcing suggests placing its Top 10 in the matrix.

Where the structure comes from

The site refers to the work of Zimmerman and the Plexus Institute. Ralph Stacey proposed a matrix that locates management decisions by degree of certainty and level of agreement. Zimmerman presented it in the Edgeware Aides of the Plexus Institute. Close to agreement and certainty, management plans and compares the results with the plan. Far from agreement but close to certainty, politics takes over: coalitions, negotiation and compromise. Close to agreement but far from certainty, a shared mission or vision replaces the plan. Far from both, the situation turns to anarchy. The organisation must avoid it. Between these regions lies a large zone of complexity, which others call the edge of chaos. Zimmerman places creativity and innovation there.

Zimmerman also describes a simplified version with four categories: simple, complicated, complex and anarchy. She used it at a retreat that brought together the board and the staff of a non-profit organisation. The groups sorted the questions of the past year, then examined the methods applied to each. Liberating Structures names the fourth category "chaotic".

In a 2002 interview, Zimmerman attributes the recipe, rocket and child analogies to the paper she wrote with Sholom Glouberman on complicated and complex systems. The book and the site add the donkey for chaotic.

The names of the types recall the domains of Cynefin.

AI considerations

Before the session, the facilitator describes the team's context to an AI assistant to prepare the introduction of the matrix template. The assistant proposes an example from this context for each type. The facilitator keeps the ones that the participants will recognise.

On an online whiteboard, the assistant groups the challenges that several participants worded differently. Between sessions, it does the same work on the individual lists of the book's version. After the session, it transcribes the photo of the wall into the table of mismatches: each challenge, its zone, the current method and the action step. The group checks each row.

The placement stays with the group. The agreement axis concerns the agreement among the people present. The assistant has no access to it. Certainty depends on the history of the organisation, which the assistant does not know. A placement proposed by the assistant would give a position without the discussion behind it.

The challenges often name projects, departments or people. The facilitator submits them only to an AI service that their organisation authorises.

The authors say nothing about AI. These uses are a practitioner's judgement.

Examples

In this illustrative case, the IT department of a cantonal administration places four challenges on the matrix, then compares them with its current methods. It follows the book's invitation: the group judges the method of each challenge.

low

Agreement

high

SimpleComplicatedComplexChaoticCurrent method:rollout plan witha single dateCurrent method:working group ofsix departments1234

high

Certainty

low

1Office software licences
2Migration of the residents' register
3Municipalities' online counterCurrent method: rollout plan with a single date
4Counter opening hours pageCurrent method: working group of six departments
Challenge placed by the group
Toward the zone of the current method
Illustrative case. The IT department of a cantonal administration places four challenges on the matrix. An arrow links a challenge to the zone where the method that handles it today belongs. Challenges 3 and 4 receive a method of another type.
ChallengeType placedCurrent methodSuitable?Action step
1. Renew the office software licences every yearSimpleStandard purchasing procedureYesKeep the method
2. Migrate the residents' register database to a new versionComplicatedMigration plan drawn up by the supplier and the architectsYesKeep the method
3. Get the municipalities to use the online counterComplexRollout plan with a single go-live date for all municipalitiesNo: the type calls for distributed trialsTrial in three volunteer municipalities. Review after two months.
4. Update the counter opening hours pageSimpleWorking group of six departments that meets every monthNo: the type calls for best practicesOne person updates the page following a written procedure
Illustrative case. The cantonal IT department's table of mismatches. Challenges 3 and 4 receive a method of another type.

The single-date plan assumes that every municipality will react as planned. The trial shows how three municipalities react before the canton extends the counter to the others. Row 4 shows the reverse mismatch: six departments jointly handle a task that a procedure settles.

Visualisations

One diagram locates the four zones on the two axes. A second shows at which step each version of the sequence has the participants place the challenges and compare the methods. A third places the challenges of an illustrative case and marks its mismatches. The four types and the table of mismatches fit in rows and columns.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowDefine which challenges the exercise covers. Print the wall matrix and one matrix per participant. Prepare one example per type from the context.
ExecutionMediumThe book gives it 45 minutes. The site gives about 50. The whole team or unit concerned takes part.
DocumentationLowPhotograph the wall. Keep the table of mismatches with the action steps.

Tooling

In person, a large sheet of paper fixed to a long wall carries the shared matrix. Each participant receives a blank matrix on an A4 page, sticky notes and a marker. The site's two visuals hang on the wall or appear on screen.

Online, a digital whiteboard such as Miro or Mural carries the matrix as its background. Each group sticks its notes on it. The videoconferencing tool opens the breakout rooms.

A spreadsheet or a shared document holds the table of mismatches. At its next session, the group returns to the actions it decided.

Sources

Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless developed the structure. Ralph Stacey proposed the matrix of agreement and certainty. Brenda Zimmerman presented and simplified it.

Agile Release Planning
All techniques
AI Canvas