Your Training Partner
Techniques Toolbox
One cycle of 1-2-4-All for a group of twelve people. The durations come from the Field Guide. In the "Alone" step (1 minute), twelve people write at the same time. In pairs (2 minutes), six conversations run in parallel. In fours (4 minutes), three conversations run in parallel. In the plenary (5 minutes), one conversation brings the whole room together. A row above shows a 12-minute open discussion where one person speaks at a time. The conversation count is calculated for this group of twelve.

1-2-4-All

1-2-4-All is a meeting structure in four timed steps. Each person thinks about a question alone, then discusses it in pairs, then in fours. Each group of four then shares one idea with the whole room. Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless designed it and describe it in The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures (2013). They offer it in place of the "Any questions?" round and the open discussion. The Field Guide in their book times one cycle at 12 minutes.

Goal

1-2-4-All is a facilitation structure that has a group answer the same question in four configurations: alone, in pairs, in fours, then all together.

The structure shares out speaking time. According to Lipmanowicz and McCandless, a few people dominate an open discussion as soon as the group grows. In 1-2-4-All, all the pairs talk at the same time, then all the groups of four. Everyone gets the same time without waiting for someone to grant it.

It feeds a decision without making it: the group selects questions, ideas or priorities for what comes next. The deliverable is the list of ideas that the groups of four share in the plenary. Each group shares one idea. In a large group, one person also records what the plenary did not hear.

1-2-4-All takes a few minutes of a workshop. In brainstorming, a group produces ideas aloud. 1-2-4-All has everyone write before anyone speaks. The authors recommend it as the first structure to try. In their view, it fits almost any meeting. You'll find the other structures in the repertoire in the Liberating Structures fiche.

Usage

When to use it

  • After a presentation: replace "Any questions?" with a cycle in which each listener writes before the group pools its ideas.
  • Elicitation workshop where a few voices dominate: the silent minute and the pair get everyone speaking before the plenary.
  • Group that waits for its manager's opinion: each idea passes through a pair and a group of four before it reaches the manager.
  • Discussion that is stuck or going round in circles: a 12-minute cycle gets the whole room writing on a reframed question.
  • Problem or innovation opportunity to open up: the group produces its first ideas before an expert presents theirs.
  • Tasks to prioritise and arguments to be heard: the groups of four sort them and the plenary keeps one priority per group.
  • High-stakes decision: participants read the documents before the session and a cycle replaces the presentations.
  • Reorganisation or new tool: the cycle gives a voice to the people the change affects.
  • Large group: the number of groups is unlimited. The cycle keeps its length if the plenary stops at three or four ideas.
  • Step in another structure: TRIZ, Simple Ethnography and Integrated~Autonomy use it to generate or sort ideas.
  • Distributed team: the breakout rooms of a video call form the pairs, then the groups of four.

When not to use it

  • Information that nobody in the room holds: in our view, look for it through document analysis or ask the people who hold it.
  • Choice between known options with no argument to develop: in our view, count the preferences with dot voting or a decision matrix.
  • Confidential or personal subject: each person shares their ideas with their partner and then with their group of four. In our view, an individual interview fits better.

Description

What the structure changes in a meeting

Lipmanowicz and McCandless describe every meeting format in terms of the same elements: the invitation, the space and materials, how participation is distributed, how groups are configured, the sequence of steps and their timing. In their view, the presentation, the status report and the managed discussion constrain who speaks too tightly. The open discussion and the brainstorm constrain it too loosely. The Field Guide is the fourth part of the book and describes each structure in terms of these elements.

ElementOpen discussionManaged discussion1-2-4-All
InvitationReact to the topic as each person sees itAnswer the chair's questionsAnswer an open question about a shared problem
Space and materialsOne or more groups in fixed seats. Microphones if neededA conference table or a classroom. The chair sits at the head of the tableRoom to face each other in pairs, then in fours. Paper for notes. Chairs and tables optional
ParticipationEveryone speaks when they want for as long as they wantThe chair, power or expertise distributes itEveryone has an equal opportunity to contribute
Group configurationThe same from start to finishThe same from start to finish and often from one meeting to the nextAlone, in pairs, in fours, then all
Steps and timingA reminder of the topic, then the discussion. Variable lengthThe agenda or the chair sets the lengthFour steps of 1, 2, 4 and 5 minutes
Open discussion, managed discussion and 1-2-4-All described in terms of the same elements. Sources: chapter 2 and the Field Guide of the book.

The invitation

The invitation is the question that the facilitator puts to the group. The Field Guide frames it in response to the presentation of an issue, a problem to resolve or a proposal. Its examples are "What opportunities do YOU see for making progress on this challenge?", "How would you handle this situation?" and "What ideas or actions do you recommend?" After a presentation, chapter 3 asks each person what questions, comments or suggestions it raises for them. For a decision, Craig Yeatman asked each person to write a numerical two-year projection of the business with and without the option. The book reports this practitioner's case in an interview in its third part.

The facilitator displays the invitation for the whole cycle. A closed question makes the pair step useless: the pair confirms one answer instead of developing several. A question that signals the expected answer has the same effect.

The room and the materials

The room must let participants face each other in pairs, then in fours. Tables for four make the transitions easier, but participants can also stand. In a large room, a microphone carries each group's idea to the plenary.

The authors' page sets a minimum of four participants. The facilitator usually stays outside the groups: they keep time. Online, the authors' page allows breakout rooms of two or three people at the pair step. In person, the participant left over likewise joins a pair and forms a trio. In our view, this trio then joins a pair to form a group of five at the next step.

The steps of the cycle

The Field Guide times one cycle at 12 minutes.

Step and durationParticipantsFacilitator
Alone (1 min)Each person reflects on the invitation in silence and notes their ideas.Enforces the silence and asks everyone to note their ideas.
In pairs (2 min)The pairs generate ideas from each person's notes.Signals the transition.
In fours (4 min)Two pairs join. The group pools the pairs' ideas, develops them and notes their similarities and differences.Signals the transition.
All (5 min)Each group shares one idea with the whole room.Signals the transition. Asks each group: "What is one idea that stood out in your conversation?" Invites the groups not to repeat an idea already shared. In a large group, limits the plenary to three or four ideas. Runs a second cycle if needed.
The steps of a cycle according to the Field Guide: what the participants and the facilitator do.

Timing by source

The authors have published durations other than those in the Field Guide.

SourceAloneIn pairsIn foursAllStated duration
Book, Field Guide1 min2 min4 min5 min12 min
Book, chapter 31 min2 min2 min3 min3 to 15 min per cycle
The authors' 1-2-4-All page1 min, after a 1-min introduction2 min5 min7 minAbout 15 min
The durations of the 1-2-4-All steps by source. Each row follows a single source.

According to chapter 3, a question that needs more than fifteen minutes calls for a second cycle: two cycles of ten minutes are better than one cycle of twenty. The steps on the authors' page add up to 16 minutes against the 15 it states.

Why the structure works

The structure demands no facilitation skill: according to the authors, you only have to be able to count to four. It gives everyone more speaking time. In the silent minute, thoughts that would otherwise stay in people's heads surface and get written down. The authors call this silence extremely valuable and consistently underused in meetings.

In their view, the pair offers the safest space to put a thought into words for the first time: everyone in a pair speaks at least a little. A controversial idea gains most from the group of four, which discusses and sifts it before the room hears it. In the plenary, each idea arrives in turn and on equal terms, whatever the personality of its author. Each participant restates their idea in the pair, then in the four. According to the authors, this repetition gives the idea depth and meaning. They add that participants own the ideas they produced. Implementation then needs less persuasion.

The authors sum up the mechanism as "parallel versus linear processing". A discussion strings individual contributions one after another. In 1-2-4-All, a group of twelve holds six conversations in pairs at the same time, then three in fours.

Open discussion12 min
one person speaks at a time
Alone1 min
12 people write
In pairs2 min
6 conversations
In fours4 min
3 conversations
All5 min
1 conversation
One cycle of 1-2-4-All for a group of twelve people. The durations come from the Field Guide. In the "Alone" step (1 minute), twelve people write at the same time. In pairs (2 minutes), six conversations run in parallel. In fours (4 minutes), three conversations run in parallel. In the plenary (5 minutes), one conversation brings the whole room together. A row above shows a 12-minute open discussion where one person speaks at a time. The conversation count is calculated for this group of twelve.

Our calculation uses the Field Guide durations and assumes that each person takes half the time of their pair and a quarter of the time of their group of four. Each participant then speaks for about one minute in the pair and one minute in the four. Before the plenary, each participant has written for one minute and spoken for two. This time does not depend on the size of the group. A twelve-minute open discussion gives each of twelve participants one minute of speaking time on average. With twenty-four participants, the average drops to thirty seconds. According to the authors, a few people dominate such a discussion.

In four experiments, Michael Diehl and Wolfgang Stroebe (1987) compared brainstorming groups with people who produced ideas alone. Production blocking is the constraint that only one voice can speak at a time: while one member speaks, the others wait. According to their results, this blocking explains most of the productivity loss in groups. This result is consistent with the choice to have everyone write before any exchange.

In teaching, Frank Lyman's Think-Pair-Share routine (1981) follows a similar order: a time for individual reflection, then an exchange in pairs.

Running the cycle

A silent minute that is cut short or interrupted hands the fastest speakers back the advantage that the structure takes from them. The others start the pair with no idea written down and take up their neighbour's.

The Field Guide and the authors' site ask the facilitator to keep the timing precise. The authors' page asks them not to overhelp or overcontrol the groups. Among the structure's purposes, the Field Guide lists avoiding overhelping and the vicious cycle of overcontrol and dependency: the more the facilitator controls, the more the group depends on them.

During the steps in pairs and in fours, the authors ask that idea generation stay separate from the plenary discussion. The group defers judgment and makes its ideas visible. When a conversation hits a plateau, the group switches to another form of expression: improv, sketching or stories.

In the plenary, one conversation runs at a time. In a large group, a harvester records what the groups did not share. The harvester also collects the groups' sheets.

Variations

The Field Guide suggests recording ideas graphically as the groups deliver them. It also suggests sticky notes during the steps in pairs and in fours. Another variation moves from groups of four to groups of eight to aim for consensus. The authors use the name that their colleague Liz Rykert gives it: Octopus.

The authors' page suggests running a second round. In What I Need From You, groups organised by function use 1-2-4-All or its short form 1-2-All, which skips the step in fours.

What makes 1-2-4-All fail

In our view, when the facilitator states the invitation without displaying it, each group answers its own question and the plenary can no longer compare the ideas.

A plenary in which each group reads out its whole list produces repetition and tires the room. The rule of one idea per group and no repeats prevents this.

A facilitator who joins a group or comments on the ideas takes back the control that the structure distributes. In our view, a manager who pairs with a direct report has the same effect. The facilitator then reshuffles the pairs.

1-2-4-All inside other structures

The Field Guide uses 1-2-4-All in one step of some fifteen other structures. The host structure sets the invitation and the duration.

StructureWhat the step produces with 1-2-4-AllDuration
TRIZThree successive lists: what would produce the worst result, what the group already does that resembles it, the first steps to stop it10 min per list
Appreciative InterviewsThe conditions that favour success and what the group can do more of10 min
Improv PrototypingFor each group of observers, what worked and what failed in the scene acted out in front of them5 min
Simple EthnographyThe patterns and unusual solutions in the observation notes15 min
Integrated~AutonomyThe tensions between standardisation and autonomy, then the priority actions10 min per list
Drawing TogetherIn a large group, what the drawings show5 min
Field Guide structures that use 1-2-4-All in one step: what the step produces and how long it takes.

Chapter 6 also proposes strings in which 1-2-4-All takes the result of one structure and feeds the next. After TRIZ, 1-2-4-All generates new ideas. With 15% Solutions, each person then names what they can do right away. Finally, Troika Consulting gives each person the advice of two peers. After a Fishbowl in which a few volunteers describe their experience, 1-2-4-All has the room formulate Wicked Questions: the paradoxical goals that the group must pursue together. You'll find how to nest and string structures in the Liberating Structures fiche.

AI considerations

A language model helps prepare the invitation. The facilitator gives it the topic and asks for several open questions modelled on the Field Guide examples. They discard the questions that call for a yes or no and those that suggest the answer.

After the session, the model transcribes the photos of the sheets and sticky notes. It groups the duplicates and sorts the ideas by theme. An analyst can also have it compare the plenary list with the backlog or the requirements register to spot what is missing. The group validates this sorting: the model does not know which idea the room judged important.

The model replaces none of the four steps. A list of ideas generated and displayed before the silent minute gives the whole room the same starting point: everyone comments on the list instead of writing their own ideas. In a group of four, an AI assistant would bring generic ideas: the structure exists to bring out what the participants know about their organisation.

Workshop sheets often name colleagues, clients or incidents. These are personal data within the meaning of the Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP). The facilitator removes the names before sending the photos to an external AI service.

Examples

The deliverable fits on one sheet. The plenary fills one column with one idea per group. The harvester fills the other with what the groups did not share.

GroupShared in the plenaryRecorded by the harvester
AGarages register vehicles for their customers: who signs the online application?Payment by QR-bill · Processing time announced to the customer
BThe vehicle inspection report arrives on paper: how is it attached to the file?Interchangeable plates
CCustomers without an account on the cantonal portal stay at the counter.Counter opening hours after the launch
DA vehicle holder moves in from another canton: who checks their address?Garages' signature (already shared by A)
Constructed case. A cantonal road traffic office presented online vehicle registration to sixteen counter staff. Invitation: "What obstacles do you see to opening vehicle registration online?" The sixteen staff form four groups of four for one cycle.

Group D had put the garages' signature at the top of its list. Group A had already shared it. D therefore shared its second idea and the harvester recorded the first. The analyst then enters each obstacle in the project's requirements register or risk register.

Visualisations

A diagram counts the simultaneous conversations at each step of a cycle for a group of twelve. It compares them with an open discussion where one person speaks at a time. Tables carry the rest: what the participants and the facilitator do at each step, the meeting formats compared, the published timings, the structures that use 1-2-4-All and the harvest sheet.

Cost

PhaseLevelJustification
PreparationLowWrite the invitation and set up the room for pairs and groups of four. Paper, pens and a bell.
ExecutionLow12 minutes per cycle according to the Field Guide. A second cycle doubles the time.
DocumentationLowOne sheet with the plenary's ideas and the harvest. A photo preserves it.

Tooling

Each participant has paper and a pen. The facilitator announces the transitions with a bell and displays a timer. A flipchart holds the plenary's ideas and the harvest.

Online, Zoom or Microsoft Teams provide the breakout rooms. The facilitator prepares the room assignment so that two pairs set in advance meet in the same room for the step in fours. They plan time on top of the step timings to open the rooms at each transition. A collaborative whiteboard (Miro, Mural) holds each group's notes.

Sources

Henri Lipmanowicz and Keith McCandless created 1-2-4-All. The book is published under a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 3.0 licence. The authors' site publishes the structures under a BY-SA 4.0 licence.

  • Henri Lipmanowicz, Keith McCandless, The Surprising Power of Liberating Structures: Simple Rules to Unleash a Culture of Innovation, 2013, ISBN 978-0-615-89337-2: the usual meeting formats described in terms of their elements (chapter 2), 1-2-4-All in action, its timing and why it works (chapter 3), the structure to start with (chapter 5), the strings (chapter 6), the interview with Craig Yeatman (part three), the description of 1-2-4-All and the structures that use it (Field Guide, part four).
  • 1-2-4-All, Liberating Structures: the online version with its one-minute introduction and its durations, its practical applications and the minimum of four participants.
  • Michael Diehl, Wolfgang Stroebe, "Productivity Loss in Brainstorming Groups: Toward the Solution of a Riddle", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53(3), 1987, pp. 497-509: production blocking.
  • Project Zero, Harvard Graduate School of Education, Think Pair Share: the classroom routine and its reference to Lyman (1981).
All techniques
10-10-10